Mark Madden Pregame Show - Steelers Talk, Bucco Banter
Nov 25, 2025
Mark and Tommy dive into the Steelers' struggles, debating why the team underperforms and examining quarterback failures since Roethlisberger. They analyze George Pickens' underutilization and critique the coaching staff's decisions. Shifting to the Pirates, they discuss offseason predictions and the media's role in shaping narratives. A light-hearted segment includes a whimsical pitch for a mascot involving McCutchen. The duo wraps up with a preview of the upcoming Bills game, emphasizing strategic concerns and defensive challenges.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Aging Roster, No Complementary Football
- The Steelers suffer from an aging roster and disconnected complementary football between offense and defense.
- Mark Madden and Tom Offerman say this mismatch prevents consistent 60-minute performances and long-term improvement.
Quarterback Failings Set Team Back
- The Steelers' mishandled quarterback strategy set the franchise back years, per the hosts.
- Mark Madden argues drafting Kenny Pickett was a catastrophic error that stalled development and roster progress.
Garrett Rising, Watt Criticized
- Miles Garrett's dominant season contrasts with T.J. Watt's perceived decline and lack of playoff success.
- Hosts predict Garrett will be remembered among all-time defensive greats while criticizing Watt's current production.