Origins of Totalitarianism: The Jews, the Nation-State, and the Birth of Antisemitism
Oct 5, 2023
auto_awesome
In this podcast, they discuss the distinction between social and political antisemitism, the paradoxes surrounding Jewish identity and privileges, the complex relationship between equality and privileges in the emancipation of Jews, Hannah Arendt's ideas on the identification of Jews, the emergence of political antisemitism and societal discrimination, and exploring responsibility, choice, and antisemitism in totalitarianism.
Modern antisemitism is an ideological movement that blames Jews for political and social problems.
Jewish privileges allowed for equality without complete assimilation into society.
Political antisemitism arose when different social classes clashed with Jewish group interests.
Deep dives
Understanding the Emergence of Political Antisemitism
In this podcast episode, Roger Berkowitz discusses chapter two of Hannah Arendt's book, 'The Origins of Totalitarianism,' which focuses on the emergence of political antisemitism. Berkowitz explains that Arendt distinguishes between social and political antisemitism, and highlights the historical shift from ancient and medieval antisemitism to modern antisemitism. Arendt argues that modern antisemitism is an ideological movement that provides quasi-scientific arguments for blaming Jews for political and social problems. She further breaks down modern antisemitism into political and social dimensions, emphasizing the dangerous nature of political antisemitism, as it seeks to curtail the rights of Jews as citizens. Arendt suggests that the interaction between the rise and fall of the nation-state and the association of Jews with the state played a significant role in the emergence of political antisemitism. She explores the idea that social discrimination against Jews paved the way for political antisemitism and examines the shift from social to political discrimination. Arendt concludes that understanding this shift in antisemitism is crucial for comprehending its impact.
The Equivocalities of Emancipation and Jewish Privileges
Within the podcast episode, Berkowitz delves into the chapter's examination of Jewish emancipation and privileges. Arendt highlights the contradictions of Jewish emancipation, noting that Jews gained equality through privileges granted by the state. She emphasizes the distinction between equality and privileges, asserting that Jews received privileges as a means of achieving equality without fully assimilating into society. Arendt discusses the connection between Jewish privileges and the relationship between Jews and the state, emphasizing how these privileges allowed Jews to maintain their distinct identity as Jews. Additionally, she explains how the association of the Jews with the state led to the emergence of anti-Semitic parties that focused on challenging Jewish rights and advocating discrimination against Jews.
The Rise of Political Antisemitism
Berkowitz discusses the historical development of political antisemitism within the podcast episode. He describes how different classes in society, such as the nobility, bourgeoisie, and lower middle classes, became anti-Semitic when they found themselves in conflict with the state. Arendt's argument suggests that antisemitic sentiment gained political relevance when it combined with major political issues or when Jewish group interests clashed with those of significant social classes. Berkowitz points out that this form of political antisemitism originated in the late 19th century, particularly during times of financial scandals, leading to the rise of anti-Semitic parties. These parties claimed to be above other political groups and super-national, aiming to unite ethnic groups across national borders. Berkowitz also highlights leftist anti-Semitism in Austria, which sought to create ties with Germans outside of Austria and viewed the state as an obstacle to their goals.
Responsibility and Choices
The discussion within the podcast episode explores the complexities of individual choices and responsibility in relation to the Jewish community. Berkowitz clarifies that Arendt does not place blame on Jews nor hold them morally responsible for the emergence of antisemitic ideologies. He emphasizes that her focus is on understanding how historical circumstances, privileges, and associations shaped the political situation for Jews and contributed to the rise of political antisemitism. The podcast underlines how choices made by Jews were restricted due to the limited options available to them in society and how these choices were largely influenced by external forces beyond their control. Berkowitz also notes that Arendt's analysis highlights the need to recognize the shift from social discrimination to political discrimination and the importance of understanding this transformation to comprehend the progression toward totalitarianism.
Challenging Interpretations of Causes and Blame
Berkowitz addresses the complexity of interpreting historical causes and assigning blame within the context of the podcast episode. He acknowledges that different scholars may hold contrasting views on the role of nationalism and religion in relation to antisemitism. However, he argues that Arendt's primary focus is not on historical accuracy but on comprehending totalitarianism. Berkowitz emphasizes that Arendt's goal is to understand the emergence of ideological antisemitism and its connection to political entities rather than assigning blame to specific groups. He highlights the book's exploration of the association between antisemitism and anti-statism, with antisemitism serving as an essential component of totalitarianism.
This episode of Reading Hannah Arendt with Roger Berkowitz deals with Chapter 2 of Origins of Totalitarianism: The Jews, the Nation-State, and the Birth of Antisemitism. Our podcast follows the book that we are reading in our current Virtual Reading Group (VRG), which meets weekly on Fridays at 1 PM EST. We are currently reading Arendt's classic analysis of the 20th century, The Origins of Totalitarianism. In Origins, Arendt tracks the rise of Fascism and Communism and explores what differentiates these regimes from past authoritarian systems.
THE HOST
Roger Berkowitz is Founder and Academic Director of the Hannah Arendt Center at Bard College. He is editor of The Perils of Invention: Lying, Technology, and the Human Condition and co-editor of Thinking in Dark Times: Hannah Arendt on Ethics and Politics (2009), and Artifacts of Thinking: Reading Hannah Arendt's Denktagebuch (2017). Berkowitz edits HA: The Journal of the Hannah Arendt Center and the weekly newsletter Amor Mundi. He is the winner of the 2019 Hannah Arendt Prize for Political Thought given by the Heinrich Böll Foundation in Germany.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode