Judith Miller, influential reporter on the narrative about weapons of mass destruction during the Iraq invasion, discusses how she got the story wrong. The podcast explores the media's support for the Bush administration's narrative and the New York Times' decision not to publish a potentially impactful story. It also reflects on the consequences of journalists' decisions and the role of accuracy in journalism.
Judith Miller brought a story about a potential major terrorist attack to an editor before 9/11, but it was never published due to insufficient details and uncertainties surrounding the source.
Media, including Judith Miller, largely supported the Bush administration's narrative on weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, raising questions about why many reporters were uncritical and Miller took the blame for the media's failure to challenge the government's claims.
Deep dives
The Missed Scoop on 9/11 Attack
In this podcast episode, the editor-in-chief of ProPublica, Steven Engelberg, recounts a missed opportunity to publish a story about an intercept of a conversation between two members of Al-Qaeda, just a couple of weeks before the 9/11 attack. The reporter, Judith Miller, brought the story to Engelberg, revealing plans by terrorists to launch a major attack against the United States. However, due to insufficient details and uncertainties surrounding the source, the story never ran. Engelberg reflects on the decision to spike the story and ponders the potential impact it could have had if published, including the possibility of altering history.
Media Credulity and WMD misinformation
This episode explores the media's role in the lead-up to the Iraq War and the erroneous reporting on weapons of mass destruction (WMDs) in Iraq. Journalists, including Judith Miller, largely backed the narrative of the administration, even when the evidence was thin. The podcast raises questions about why so many reporters were credulous and explores Miller's role in taking the fall for the media's failure to accurately assess and challenge the government's claims about WMDs.
This episode is member-exclusive. Listen to it now by subscribing to Slate Plus. By joining, not only will you unlock exclusive Slow Burn episodes, but you’ll also access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe now on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Or, visit slate.com/slowburnplus to get access wherever you listen.
In the months before the invasion of Iraq, the media mostly backed the Bush administration’s narrative about weapons of mass destruction. No reporter was more influential on that beat than the New York Times' Judith Miller.
How did she get the story so wrong—and why was she the only person to take the fall?
Season 5 of Slow Burn is produced by Noreen Malone, Jayson De Leon, and Sophie Summergrad. Mixing by Merritt Jacob.