Last season, Dylan surprised Dalton by composing four original songs for his Dark Universe take on The Phantom of the Opera. "Fuck," said Dalton, "Now I have to do a musical episode!" It's finally here, and it does not disappoint. The Phantom of the Opera: Love Never Dies is a new Dark Universe story, a sequel to Dylan's Phantom, a riff on Andrew Lloyd Webber's Love Never Dies, and a fully produced musical EP! What does Dalton have in store for everyone's favorite monster hunting power couple, Carol and Jenny? One thing's for sure: This episode's gonna get people talking.

Guest starring Ella Dawson as Jenny Halsey and Steph Salo as Carol Laemmle!

Our partner podcast this week is Finding Monster Right, where hosts Adam and Allie answer questions you've never asked about monsters from folklore, pop culture, and our own world.

00:00:00 - Start

00:08:17 - Fan Expectations

00:13:37 - Director Choice

00:17:14 - Act One

00:21:45 - “Previously On!”

00:25:55 - Discussion

00:28:34 - Act One Continued

00:44:20 - “Carol’s Lament”

00:48:20 - Act One Continued

00:49:26 - Discussion

01:01:34 - Act Two

01:15:01 - Discussion

01:22:09 - Act Two Continued

01:39:17 - “The Raven”

01:42:55 - Discussion

01:51:21 - Act Two Continued

01:58:24 - Discussion

02:06:22 - Act Three

02:18:20 - “Carol’s Lament (Reprise)”

02:20:20 - Act Three Continued

02:25:18 - Mid-Credits Scene

02:27:13 - Discussion

02:39:52 - Post-Credits Scene

02:42:49 - Discussion