Words, Actions, and Liberty: Tara Smith Decodes the First Amendment
Oct 12, 2024
auto_awesome
Tara Smith, a Professor of Philosophy at the University of Texas at Austin, dives into the complexities of the First Amendment and free speech. She discusses historical figures like Locke and Jefferson while tackling modern issues like cancel culture and social media censorship. Smith explores the critical distinction between speech and action, the implications of freedom in different societies, and the responsibilities of individuals in understanding their rights. The conversation emphasizes the necessity for a free press and personal accountability in the age of misinformation.
Tara Smith emphasizes the First Amendment's role in protecting not just free speech but also freedom of religion, press, and assembly for intellectual liberty.
The conversation evaluates the complexities of rights, asserting that genuine rights should not conflict, unlike contemporary debates over issues like abortion and free expression.
Smith highlights the importance of engaging with controversial philosophers like Ayn Rand, arguing that her unique perspective enriches philosophical discourse on rights and freedoms.
Deep dives
Value of Papa Murphy's Offerings
The $7.99 everyday value lineup at Papa Murphy's showcases their commitment to providing affordable yet flavorful pizza options. This range includes popular choices like the bold shredded pepperoni pizza, savory crumbled sausage pizza, and classic cheese pizza, all freshly made. By pricing these large pizzas at a competitive rate, Papa Murphy's not only promotes accessibility to delicious meals but also caters to various customer preferences. This initiative aims to encourage families and individuals to enjoy take-and-bake pizzas daily, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Exploring Academic Philosophy
The speaker describes their journey into philosophy, initially kindled by interests in law and politics during high school and college. They found a deeper engagement in philosophy classes compared to political theory courses, ultimately choosing to double major in both fields. Inspired by a passionate professor, they aspired to develop a career in academic philosophy, focusing particularly on Ayn Rand's influence. Their commitment to philosophy has enabled them to explore fundamental questions about individual freedom and morality.
Ayn Rand's Academic Reception
The discussion addresses Rand's controversial reception in academic circles, noting how her emphasis on strong philosophical positions has garnered both criticism and acclaim. The speaker argues for taking Rand seriously, highlighting her ability to engage deeply with philosophical arguments and address objections. They assert that Rand's unique style, emerging from her background as a novelist, differentiates her from traditional academic discourse yet enriches philosophical dialogue. The recent resurgence in interest surrounding her works reflects a broader reevaluation of her contributions to political and ethical discussions.
Intellectual Freedom and the First Amendment
A key theme is the understanding of the First Amendment as encompassing broader intellectual freedom beyond mere freedom of speech. The speaker emphasizes that the amendment also protects freedom of religion, freedom of the press, and the right to assemble, all contributing to a foundation of intellectual liberty. They argue that Ayn Rand championed these principles, advocating for individual rights and freedoms essential for intellectual and material well-being. The speaker suggests contemporary issues surrounding free speech and religious exemptions should be examined through this lens of intellectual freedom.
Defining Rights and Moral Values
The discussion explores the concept of rights, emphasizing that moral rights exist independently of legal recognition and must resolve conflicts between individuals. The speaker argues that genuine rights cannot conflict since their purpose is to delineate personal freedoms. They highlight contemporary examples of conflicting rights, such as those related to abortion and freedom of expression, to illustrate the complexities of moral philosophy in practice. By advocating for a clear understanding of rights, the speaker seeks to foster more constructive dialogues around contentious issues, urging a foundation of reasoned analysis rather than polarized positions.
First Amendment scholar and philosopher Tara Smith offers a comprehensive analysis of free speech, situating her work within the broader intellectual landscape. She examines the perspectives of historical figures like John Locke, Thomas Jefferson, and John Stuart Mill while addressing contemporary issues such as social media speech, “cancel culture,” and religious exemptions. Smith’s approach involves dissecting key concepts like censorship and freedom, exploring the crucial distinction between speech and action.
Tara Smith is Professor of Philosophy at the University of Texas at Austin, where she has taught since 1989. A specialist in moral, legal, and political philosophy, she is author of the books Judicial Review in an Objective Legal System (Cambridge University Press, 2015), Ayn Rand’s Normative Ethics: The Virtuous Egoist (Cambridge, 2006), Viable Values: A Study of Life as the Root and Reward of Morality (Rowman and Littlefield, 2000), and Moral Rights and Political Freedom (Rowman and Littlefield 1995). Smith’s scholarly articles span such subjects as rights conflicts, the morality of money, everyday justice, forgiveness, friendship, pride, moral perfection, and the value of spectator sports.
Shermer and Smith discuss the First Amendment, the definition of freedom, the nature of rights, and how freedoms are won or lost. The conversation explores contemporary issues such as social media censorship, hate speech, and the blurring lines between speech and action. It also delves into legal concepts like libel, slander, and compelled speech. Historical context is provided through references to influential figures like Oliver Wendell Holmes and his introduction of the clear and present danger test in First Amendment law.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
