
Born Free Method: The Podcast Living with Uncertainty: Fertility, Pregnancy, and Childbirth
[00:02:23] - Intro
Your due date is March 14th. A single, confident, perfectly circled square on the calendar, handed over by a smiling professional with a plastic wheel. And God help us, we believe them. We want a date so badly that we will take one from a cardboard dial, knowing full well that only about one baby in twenty is punctual on their appointed day. When the date rolls past with no baby yet to speak of, people start asking questions. They start to pressure you into evacuating your unborn child from their warm, amniotic universe. Because there’s a new numbers game at play. “Your baby could die if they wait too long to be born”. Childbirth is ripe with opportunity to examine our ongoing challenges in making predictions and ascertaining risk.Why are human beings so bad at judging risk, and why does it feel even harder in high stakes games like childbirth? Fertility, pregnancy, and birth offer a lot of uncertainty. You are forced to make decisions with never a guarantee of outcome. To understand why decision-making is so hard in the face of uncertainty, we have to drag four modern witnesses into the light: Nassim Nicholas Taleb, Daniel Kahneman, Amos Tversky, and Gerd Gigerenzer. They do not agree on much, but they have contemplated the same wound.
[00:03:50] - The Problem is Not New
The troubles we face in decision-making around risk are not new. In the 1700s, a Scottish philosopher named David Hume noticed that we tend to play tricks on ourselves to uphold our faith in whatever tomorrow brings. The sun has come up every morning of your life, so you assume it will come up again. But yesterday’s sunrise does not guarantee a sunrise tomorrow. Your first pregnancy was easy, so surely your second will be, too. All of your friends and family skated through childbirth, so you’ve got this in the bag. Your Instagram followers are also rooting for you because you “did everything right”. You are betting that biology is a creature of habit, like the bartender who remembers your favorite cocktail. You have no proof that the future will unfold just as it did yesterday, though a streak is a streak, and sometimes that’s the best you’ve got. Philosophers call this inductive reasoning, whereby specific observations are used to formulate a generalized conclusion about the world. This is the process that leads to hypotheses and better research questions. Deductive reasoning, on the other hand, moves from general blanketed observations in order to get clear on specifics. This is the process that is used to challenge hypotheses. The pregnancy continuum and all of its advisors - credentialed or otherwise - often fall into the trap of inductive reasoning, like a moth lured to the flame. The issue is that a flame cannot cast a shadow on itself. A flame may leave you blind to the greater context of life outside of abstraction.
[00:05:17] - Black Swans
For millennia, Europeans had seen nothing but white swans and concluded, with the serene ignorance of inductive reasoning as so often practiced by the “well-informed”, that all swans were white. In 1697 some Dutch explorers wandered into Australia and found black swans, and the whole theory that all swans were white was incinerated. One black swan killed it. Karl Popper built a philosophy on this inconvenient asymmetry: you can never prove an idea true, only fail to break it. Any obstetrician will tell you the same thing in a softer voice. Ninety-nine uneventful deliveries do not make the hundredth safe. This soothing balm makes you less worried about your chances.In 1921 an economist named Frank Knight drew a sharp distinction between “risk” and “uncertainty”. Risk governs over the casino. You know the odds of your roll before you throw. Uncertainty is starting a new company in a bad economy: nobody knows the odds of you succeeding, but they don’t sound great. Fertility sits on the boundary between risk and uncertainty. The statistics are real but is the risk to your own birth truly found in the data? A young, healthy couple has roughly a one-in-five chance of conceiving in any given month, and most get there within a year. But those numbers describe a crowd, and you are not a crowd. You are one person with one body on one road, and the average does not care to learn your name. This is, in fact, the problem with the Law of Averages: nobody is average. You either fall below or above the average of something happening. Keynes made a related point, arguing that no man alive could calculate what interest rates would be in twenty years. Nobody can likewise calculate your twenty-year-old self’s answer to “when should we start trying?” So how do you navigate a dark alley, rife with uncertainty? The ancients had two answers. The Stoics, men like Seneca and Epictetus, suggested sorting life into two piles: what you control and what you do not. You can control what screenings you receive throughout your prenatal care. You can control the questions you ask. You can control where and with whom you give birth. You can control which advice you turn to in improving your chances of conceiving. But you cannot control whether conception takes two months or two years, and you certainly cannot control the outcome of your birth. Spend your effort on the first pile and make peace with the second, like a sailor who has stopped arguing with the ocean. Blaise Pascal, who in 1654 swapped letters with Fermat and helped ignite the modern discourse around probability itself, offered a more practical tool: weigh the stakes. You cannot know if labor will start early. But having all of your ducks in a row costs you almost nothing if you guess wrong.
[00:07:55] - Taleb: The Turkey Knows Nothing
Mathematician Nassim Nicholas Taleb takes this philosophical discourse straight into Wall Street. But it applies just as well to the maternity ward. Suppose you were a turkey. You are fed every day for 1,000 days by an amicable farmer. Every meal makes you more certain that the farmer is your dearest friend, your guardian angel in overalls. On day 1,001, the day before Thanksgiving, you wake up feeling the most certain about your friendly farmer friend. But later that day, the farmer shows up with an ax.Your observations were on point. But your intuition remained silent about the one event that mattered most. Taleb calls these rare, ruinous surprises to our plans “Black Swans”. By nature, Black Swan events are always perceived as an ambush, because they don’t tabulate into our certainty about life until after they happen. In pregnancy, sudden complication are Black Swan events. Others are pregnancy losses or stillbirth that come without warning, or consider a baby who decides she is ready to come out of her warm amniotic universe 8 weeks early. Most pregnancies go fine, and that is exactly the problem with these events when we apply this framework to the pregnancy continuum. The spreadsheets of the statisticians are filled with data from healthy, unremarkable births. But the Black Swan events fill our nightmares and drive policy. After a tragedy on the maternity unit, the mind goes hunting for a reason, a sign, some “thing” that should have been done, because a story we can blame feels safer than a world where it simply happened. This fallacy is most cruel in maternity care, because in your grieving you go looking for guilt even when there may be none at all.The critics say the whole thing is hard to test because any disaster can be pointed to as a Black Swan. This is what the outspoken, authoritative, alternative health community does really well. And they are not wrong. Even Taleb admits that this point is slippery. In obstetrics, a team of professionals who has seen enough of these disasters no longer sees them as Black Swans, which is still a fallacy in and of itself. But the impact that these disasters has on both birthing families and the staff in attendance to the birth are sufficiently horrific that health care professionals plan accordingly in an effort…
Get full access to Born Free Method: The Podcast at nathanrileyobgyn.substack.com/subscribe
