Keen On America

Why "Progress" is Ruling Class Propaganda: The Dangerous Idea that Built Civilization and is Now Destroying it

Dec 6, 2025
Samuel Miller MacDonald, an author and historian, challenges the concept of progress as ruling class propaganda. He explores the origins of progress in ancient Mesopotamian market empires, suggesting they were parasitic and ecologically destructive. MacDonald emphasizes that industrialization has only intensified these issues, critiques modern elites like Gates and Thiel, and proposes alternatives like sortition and agroecology. He believes true progress lies in learning from egalitarian Indigenous societies and embracing non-extractive, sustainable futures.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Civilization As Early Market Empires

  • Civilization emerged as market empires around 5,000 years ago with regimented labour and extraction.
  • Samuel Miller MacDonald links that political economy to long-term expansionism and ecological harm.
INSIGHT

Progress Linked To Parasitic Ecology

  • McDonald describes the ecological relation of these early states as parasitic, extracting from nature and causing harm.
  • He sees that exploitative orientation as persistent across 5,000 years of 'progress' narratives.
ANECDOTE

Gilgamesh As A Deforestation Hagiography

  • McDonald interprets the Epic of Gilgamesh as celebrating deforestation used to build cities.
  • He uses that ancient story to trace the long history of extractive urban development.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app