#485: The Biggest Plot Holes in the Harry Potter Books
Oct 6, 2020
auto_awesome
Dive into the intriguing world of Harry Potter as the discussion uncovers major plot holes, like why James didn’t become his own Secret Keeper and the mystery of the Marauder’s Map. Explore how Time Turners could have changed everything and the complexities of Voldemort's character, particularly his inability to love. Delve into the mechanics of the Triwizard Cup and why the Ministry of Magic failed to prove Sirius Black’s innocence. Plus, enjoy light-hearted trivia and reflections on the implications of magical ethics!
The episode emphasizes the importance of voter registration as election deadlines near, urging listeners to ensure their participation in the democratic process.
Discussion of plot holes, such as the missing 24 hours after the Potters' murder, raises intrigue regarding character actions and narrative consistency.
Inconsistencies around magical elements like Time-Turners and the Unbreakable Vow highlight contradictions within the Harry Potter universe, prompting fan reflection.
Deep dives
The Importance of Voter Registration
The discussion highlights the critical nature of voter registration as election deadlines approach. Listeners are encouraged to check their registration status and create a voting plan to ensure participation. Resources such as IWillVote.com and BallotReady.org are recommended for gathering essential information about the voting process and ballot items. The episode emphasizes that it's essential for everyone to exercise their right to vote, regardless of political alignment.
Plot Holes in the Harry Potter Series
The episode dives into various plot holes within the Harry Potter framework, starting with the mysterious 24 hours between the Potters' murder and Harry's arrival at Privet Drive. The hosts question the whereabouts of key characters during this missing time, particularly what Dumbledore and Hagrid were doing to ensure Harry's safety. They speculate on the logistical challenges of moving a baby and setting up protective measures without addressing the events of that day. This omission raises intriguing questions among fans, leaving them contemplating narrative inconsistencies.
Voldemort's Character Depth
Listeners contribute their thoughts on Voldemort's inability to love and whether this trait is a product of his circumstances or a personal choice. Some argue that suggesting Voldemort was emotionally stunted due to his mother's use of a love potion weakens his character by removing agency over his decisions. The discourse leads to a broader discussion about how childhood experiences shape an individual’s moral compass and whether Voldemort could have chosen a different path. Critics of this plot device believe it simplifies the character into a one-dimensional villain.
Inconsistencies with Magical Rules
The episode also analyzes inconsistencies regarding magic, especially in terms of the Time-Turners and the Unbreakable Vow. Time-Turners are called out for their apparent ease in resolving complex plot situations, raising questions about their limitations. The Unbreakable Vow is scrutinized as well, particularly why Voldemort didn’t require his Death Eaters to make such vows to maintain loyalty. These magical elements create contradictions within the story, prompting fans to reflect on how the rules of magic are applied inconsistently.
The Mystery of the Marauder's Map
One of the central plot holes discussed is why Fred and George never noticed Peter Pettigrew on the Marauder's Map during his time at Hogwarts. The brothers, known for their mischievous adventures, likely would have gleaned valuable information had they spotted their former friend in his rat form. The episode suggests that the success of a plot device like the Marauder's Map hinges on the attention given to it by the characters, raising questions about its effectiveness as a storytelling tool. This leads to broader inquiries about character interactions and the potential limitations of magical artifacts.
PSA for the USA: Many voter registration deadlines are approaching in the United States. Please make sure you are registered to vote in your state right now by visiting IWillVote.com. You can also find out great ballot information at BallotReady.org and sign up to be a poll worker at PowerThePolls.org.
MuggleMail covers Dumbledore and Tom Riddle's first encounter and Voldemort's ability to love
Our Main Discussion focuses on The Biggest Plot Holes in the Harry Potter books!
The Lost Day: What was happening in those initial 24 hours after the Potters were killed?
Why didn’t James Potter become his own Secret Keeper?
Time Turners galore! Why didn’t anyone go back in time to stop Voldemort?
How is it Peter Pettigrew was never noticed on the Marauder’s Map by Fred & George?
Why didn't Lupin warn Harry about Sirius' animagus form?
How did the Triwizard Cup function as a (reverse) portkey to bring Harry back to Hogwarts at the end of Goblet of Fire?
Why doesn’t Voldemort have all his Death Eaters make an Unbreakable Vow?
What's the deal with the trace?
The truth about Veritaserum... it could have made quite the difference!
Quizzitch: Who was Fudge’s opponent in running for Minister for Magic?
You can join our community at Patreon.com/MuggleCast and receive magical benefits, including Bonus MuggleCast!
This week's episode is brought to you by Peacock (Watch the Harry Potter movies for free all October long!) and MeUndies (get 15% off and free shipping on your first order by visiting MeUndies.com/mugglecast)
