In this engaging discussion, journalist Barry Wirth sheds light on John 'Jack' Downey, America's longest-held POW, who spent 21 years in a Chinese prison. They delve into the CIA's covert operations during the Cold War, the complexities of espionage, and the psychological resilience Downey exhibited behind bars. Wirth also reveals the struggles families faced due to misinformation and contrasts Downey's fate with that of fellow operative Gary Powers, offering a gripping perspective on resilience, identity, and the human cost of secrets.
John 'Jack' Downey's 21 years of imprisonment showcased his resilient psychological tactics to withstand harsh interrogations and maintain secrecy.
The evolution of U.S. foreign policy during the Cold War fundamentally shaped the circumstances leading to Downey's capture and eventual release.
Deep dives
The Capture of John T. Downey
John T. Downey, a CIA agent, was captured in 1952 after a covert operation in China went awry. The operation involved a daring plan to extract an undercover team that had reported success in establishing a presence in the country. However, the team had been compromised, leading Downey and his ally to fly into an ambush where they were shot down. The ambush, set by Chinese forces, was premeditated, as they knew of Downey's operation and were eager for the capture of an American spy.
The Cold War Context
During the 1950s, American foreign policy was heavily influenced by the Cold War, particularly in Asia, following the loss of China to communist forces. The U.S. reaction was to establish the CIA as a permanent spy service and engage in clandestine operations to counter communist influences. The formation of the CIA was a response to the increasing fears of communism, especially following the Soviet Union's acquisition of nuclear capabilities and China's shift to communism. This backdrop not only set the stage for Downey's covert activities but also influenced the U.S. strategies throughout the Cold War.
Downey's Imprisonment Experience
Downey endured 21 years of imprisonment, facing harsh interrogations and solitary confinement, yet remarkably managed to maintain his sanity and spirit. He strategically wrote long, convoluted 'confessions' filled with irrelevant details to buy time and protect sensitive information from his captors. This tactic effectively delayed the Chinese government's exploitation of his admissions, leading to a 3,000-page document that was both a coping mechanism and a form of psychological resistance. Over time, Downey adapted to his circumstances, believing that his government would eventually mount an effort to secure his release.
The Long Path to Freedom
It wasn't until the Nixon administration's thawing relations with China that Downey's plight garnered serious attention, leading to eventual diplomatic discussions for his release. After years of silence about his status, a gradual acknowledgment of his role as a spy opened the door for negotiations. The key to his release came when the U.S. admitted Downey was a CIA agent and began to apologize for the circumstances of his capture. Ultimately, his release was strategically linked to broader geopolitical interests, reflecting the complex web of Cold War diplomacy that underscored his story.
This is the story of America's longest held prisoner of war. John 'Jack' Downey, an American CIA operative, was imprisoned by the Chinese for 21 years during the Cold War.
Don speaks to Barry Wirth, author of 'Prisoner of Lies: Jack Downey's Cold War.' They explore why the CIA were in Asia in the 1950s, Downey's capture and imprisonment, and why it took so long for him to be released.
Produced by Sophie Gee. Edited by Aidan Lonergan. Senior Producer was Charlotte Long.
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.