Jill Rutter, a senior fellow at the Institute for Government and former civil servant, joins the hosts to unpack the political maneuvers of Keir Starmer's leadership. They discuss how new prime ministers shift government operations and examine Starmer's mission-led approach. The conversation highlights the ongoing complexities between civil servants and ministers, especially in the context of housing and criminal justice reforms. Rutter also shares insights into the Labour Party's public safety strategies and the challenges that lie ahead for the UK government.
Keir Starmer's administration prioritizes stability by minimizing changes within the cabinet and emphasizing continuity in governance despite political pressures.
Rachel Reeves underscores fiscal responsibility by revealing the government's financial challenges, indicating a pragmatic shift away from previous grand promises.
Deep dives
The Importance of Stability in Governance
Keir Starmer's administration has displayed a notable commitment to stability within its governance structure, opting for minimal changes to departmental roles and retaining many shadow cabinet members in their new posts. This approach marks a departure from previous transitions that often involved significant reshuffling or the creation of new departments in response to political pressures. Starmer's government has, however, retained the essence of mission-led governance by establishing mission boards, albeit without clearly defined objectives or names associated with them so far. This strategy underscores a preference for continuity, reflecting a desire to maintain a steady leadership style amid calls for change during the election campaign.
Mission Boards and Implementation Challenges
The concept of mission boards is intended to drive specific governmental priorities and reforms by fostering cross-departmental collaboration. Currently, however, there is skepticism about their effectiveness, as most missions appear tightly aligned with existing departmental structures rather than offering innovative frameworks for governance. The potential impact of these boards may remain underwhelming if they continue to operate without engaging key stakeholders in local government or other sectors essential for successful implementation. Ultimately, the effectiveness of these mission boards hinges on their ability to attract diverse perspectives and produce tangible results beyond traditional governmental approaches.
Fiscal Responsibility and Immediate Actions
Rachel Reeves, serving as the Chancellor, has prioritized transparency regarding the government's dire fiscal situation, revealing discrepancies between pre-election expectations and the harsh realities of the public finances. Her proactive measures, including immediate cuts to the winter fuel allowance for certain pensioners, signify a shift away from grand promises towards pragmatic governance rooted in difficult financial truths. By confronting these fiscal challenges head-on, the government is sending a message about its commitment to financial responsibility, albeit at the risk of political backlash. This balancing act between fiscal prudence and voter satisfaction poses an ongoing challenge for the administration moving forward.
Reestablishing Civil Service Relations
The new government aims to restore constructive relationships with the civil service, acknowledging its crucial role in effective policy-making and governance. Keir Starmer's administration is characterized by a significant presence of former civil servants, highlighting a shift toward valuing civil service expertise in policy formulation. This approach potentially contrasts with previous administrations that adopted a more adversarial stance towards civil servants, often sidelining their contributions in favor of political advisors. By fostering collaboration with civil servants, the current government seeks to enhance its policy-making capabilities while navigating the complexities of public governance.
How do new prime ministers change the machinery of government to help deliver their priorities? John and Rachel are joined by former civil servant Jill Rutter to discuss government transitions and what Keir Starmer has changed since taking the reins of the British state.
Guest: Jill Rutter, senior fellow at the Institute for Government and former civil servant
Hosts: John Curtice and Rachel Wolf
To find out more about Tortoise:
- Download the Tortoise app - for a listening experience curated by our journalists
- Subscribe to Tortoise+ on Apple Podcasts for early access and exclusive content
- Become a member and get access to all of Tortoise's premium audio offerings and more
If you want to get in touch with us directly about a story, or tell us more about the stories you want to hear about trendy@tortoisemedia.com