Kevin Roberts, President of the Heritage Foundation, delves into the Republican Party's ideological journey from internationalism to isolationism. Edward Carr, Deputy Editor at The Economist, emphasizes how current skepticism towards foreign alliances shapes U.S. foreign policy. They discuss the implications of recent political dynamics, military aid debates, and America's evolving role globally. The conversation also touches on historical influences, including Eisenhower's moderate stance and the challenges posed by a divided political landscape.
The Republican Party's shift towards isolationism raises concerns about America's ability to uphold commitments and alliances, potentially affecting its standing in the world.
The exception for Israel from the Republican Party's isolationist stance highlights the complexities of American foreign policy and the challenge of balancing support for allies with broader global interests.
Deep dives
The Shift from Isolationism to Internationalism
The podcast explores how the Republican Party transitioned from isolationism to internationalism and back again. It discusses the historical context of the party's shift, including the influence of figures like George Washington and Dwight D. Eisenhower. It also examines the impact of recent events, such as the rise of China, on the Republican Party's views on foreign policy.
The Impact of Isolationism on American Power
Isolationism within the Republican Party poses challenges for American power and the global order. The party's reluctance to support foreign aid, such as funding for Ukraine, undermines America's ability to uphold its commitments and alliances. This could affect America's standing in the world, as allies may question the country's reliability and adversaries may test its resolve. The shift towards isolationism also raises questions about the future of American leadership and its ability to shape the global agenda.
The Role of America in the Israel-Gaza Conflict
The Republican Party's exception for Israel from its isolationist stance highlights the complex dynamics of American foreign policy. While President Biden has expressed support for Israel, he has also emphasized the importance of minimizing casualties in Gaza. This reflects a different approach to the exercise of American power, focused on diplomacy and restraint rather than direct military intervention. The challenge for American leaders is to balance support for allies with the need to address broader global challenges and interests.
Challenges in Providing Aid to Ukraine
The Republican Party's isolationist turn presents obstacles to providing financial and military aid to Ukraine. Despite the strategic importance of supporting Ukraine's fight against Russia and deterring further aggression, some Republicans view such aid as contrary to America's national interest. The party's reluctance to commit funds and resources to Ukraine raises questions about the effectiveness of America's commitments and its willingness to act as a global leader.
On foreign policy, trade and immigration, the Republican Party wants America to push the world away. This is a departure, but also a return to what the party used to believe. How did the Republican Party go from isolationism to internationalism and then back again? And what does that mean for America’s foreign policy?
John Prideaux hosts with Charlotte Howard and Idrees Kahloon. They’re joined by Kevin Roberts, president of the Heritage Foundation, and The Economist’s Edward Carr.
Sign up for Economist Podcasts+ now and get 50% off your subscription with our limited time offer. If you’re already a subscriber to The Economist, you’ll have full access to all our shows as part of your subscription. For more information about how to access Economist Podcasts+, please visit our FAQs page or watch our video explaining how to link your account.
For full access to print, digital and audio editions, as well as exclusive live events, subscribe to The Economist at economist.com/uspod.
Podcast transcripts are available upon request at podcasts@economist.com. We are committed to improving accessibility even further and are exploring new ways to expand our podcast transcript offering.