Derek Hook, “Six Moments in Lacan: Communication and Identification in Psychology and Psychoanalysis” (Routledge, 2018)
Oct 25, 2024
auto_awesome
Derek Hook, an associate professor at Duquesne University and a Lacanian scholar, delves into the intersection of language and the unconscious. He creatively uses Bill Clinton's infamous denial to illustrate Lacan's theories. The conversation spans Nixon’s apology post-Watergate, exploring themes of responsibility and identity within political contexts. Hook emphasizes the significance of the 'big other' in shaping communication and the challenges in bridging academic and clinical worlds, offering insights into psychoanalysis and individual repression.
The interplay between Jacques Lacan's theories and Freud's work emphasizes their interconnectedness, challenging psychoanalysts to navigate complex ideas about the unconscious.
Derek Hook highlights the importance of balancing theoretical knowledge with clinical practice, demonstrating how patient interactions can enhance understanding of psychoanalytic concepts.
The dual nature of the 'big other' illustrates its critical role in communication and identity, impacting both individual experiences and societal influences in psychoanalysis.
Deep dives
Understanding Lacanian Psychoanalysis
The episode delves into the significance of Jacques Lacan's theories in psychoanalysis, particularly the interplay between his work and Freud's. The speaker explores how encountering Lacan's ideas, including his unique use of diagrams and mathematical themes, captivated his interest, leading to a lasting engagement with his theories. The speaker points out that grappling with Lacan's complex ideas often requires an understanding of Freud's theories, emphasizing the interconnectedness of the two psychoanalysts. This dynamic relationship serves as both a foundation and a challenge for those studying Lacanian psychoanalysis, illustrating the nuances of interpreting the unconscious as structured like a language.
The Dual Role of Psychoanalysts
The conversation highlights the often dichotomous nature of psychoanalysts’ roles, balancing intellectual theory with clinical practice. The speaker shares his journey through training and clinical experience, observing that firsthand engagement with patients enriches theoretical understanding. This dialectic approach demonstrates how direct interaction with patients can challenge and refine theoretical knowledge while addressing student concerns regarding the evolution of psychoanalytic thought. Such experiences underscore the importance of continuing education and adaptation within the psychoanalytic field to enhance diagnostic proficiency.
The Big Other and Communication Dynamics
The concept of the 'big other' is explored as a crucial part of communication and identification in psychoanalysis. The speaker illustrates various definitions of the big other, explaining it as both a linguistic operator and a developmental influence on individuals’ experiences. This duality underscores the significance of societal norms and historical context in shaping individual identities, emphasizing that understanding this concept is critical for psychoanalysts. The speaker notes that the big other is not only an abstract theoretical construct, but also has practical implications for patients' understanding of their relationships with authority and society.
The Influence of Language on the Unconscious
The episode discusses how language plays a pivotal role in the functioning of the unconscious, challenging traditional notions of personal identity. It illustrates this through the example of Bill Clinton's speech, highlighting how words carry meanings beyond their immediate context and can reveal hidden aspects of the speaker's psyche. The speaker emphasizes Lacan's view that the unconscious is structured like a language, proposing that language connects the individual to a collective social network. This dynamic suggests that understanding the interplay between language and the unconscious is essential for psychoanalysts, as it opens avenues for deeper exploration of clients' thoughts and feelings.
Navigating Sexuality and Trauma in Psychoanalysis
The discussion touches upon the complexities of addressing sexuality within the framework of psychoanalysis, highlighting its connection to trauma and repression. The speaker argues for a nuanced understanding of sexuality that extends beyond reductive interpretations, framing it as a critical element in human experience and subjectivity. This perspective allows for a richer dialogue about how individuals cope with difficult emotions and traumatic experiences, thereby enhancing therapeutic interactions. Moreover, this approach helps situate traditional psychoanalytic concepts within contemporary discourse, allowing practitioners to engage thoughtfully with the evolving landscape of psychological theories.
How can Bill Clinton’s “I did not have sexual relations with that woman” shed light on Lacan’s maxim, “The unconscious is structured like a language?” In Six Moments in Lacan: Communication and Identification in Psychology and Psychoanalysis (Routledge, 2018), professor Derek Hook thoroughly investigates and explains a number of Lacan’s major concepts from his structuralist period, making them accessible to a wide-ranging audience with reference to entertaining examples from popular culture. Hook argues that, while the fields of psychology and psychoanalysis share certain questions and premises, we must, as Lacan insisted, remain alert to the radical disjunction between the objectifying aims of psychology and psychoanalysis’s unique attention to the subject, conceived as an event in language. In this interview, we hear Derek explain several of his book’s key arguments, explore the clinical dimensions of Lacanian theory, and, alongside Derek’s illuminating commentary, listen to Richard Nixon confess his responsibility for Watergate.
Jordan Osserman grew up in South Florida and currently calls London home. He received his PhD in gender studies and psychoanalysis from University College London, his MA in psychosocial studies from Birkbeck College, and his BA in womens and gender studies from Dartmouth College. His published work can be found here.
