WW2 Pod: We Have Ways of Making You Talk Atlantic War: No Phoney War At Sea (Part 1)
10 snips
Nov 18, 2025 The battle of the Atlantic is dissected as a crucial front for the Allies in WWII. Al recounts the harrowing sinking of the SS Athenia and the rescue of survivors. The strategic importance of Britain’s naval capabilities shines through, while discussions reveal Germany's naval weaknesses and missed opportunities. Dönitz's wolfpack strategy for U-boats is introduced, emphasizing coordinated attacks. The episode also highlights Royal Navy losses and the vulnerability of carriers, setting the stage for the ongoing conflict at sea.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Why 'Atlantic War' Is More Accurate
- The hosts rename the campaign 'Atlantic War' to stress it was an ongoing global campaign, not a single battle.
- Control of Atlantic shipping was decisive to Allied victory because Britain's survival depended on seaborne supply.
Athenia Survivor Became A Fighter Ace
- Jimmy Goodson survived the SS Athenia sinking on 3 September 1939 and later joined the RCAF, becoming a leading ace.
- His rescue and subsequent career show how the Atlantic War directly launched individual wartime journeys.
Navy Shifted From Trafalgar To Attrition
- The Royal Navy accepted attrition and scale over single decisive battles after WWI.
- Leadership like Admiral Pound reflected a shift to operational, incremental warfare rather than Nelsonian climactic battles.
