The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast Ep. 364: Max Scheler on Sympathy (Part One)
Mar 31, 2025
Dive into Max Scheler's intriguing exploration of sympathy and fellow feeling, unraveling their ethical implications. The discussion sets apart genuine sympathy from mere identification, emphasizing the necessity for individuality in ethical understanding. From critiquing emotional engagement to examining the pitfalls of total unity, the speakers navigate the intricate relationships between empathy and personal identity. They also tackle the biological roots of moral emotions, challenging us to rethink our connections while honoring our distinct selves.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Fellow Feeling
- Fellow-feeling, encompassing pity and shared joy, involves directly grasping another person's emotional state.
- It's not replicating their pain but sensing it as an object of understanding.
Reactive Capacity
- Scheler emphasizes that fellow-feeling isn't an active reaching out to others, but a capacity to be affected by them.
- This reactivity is fundamental to how we connect with others, though not an active connection itself.
Intentionality of Fellow Feeling
- Scheler rejects causal theories, arguing that fellow-feeling is intentional, like perceiving a rose.
- We directly grasp others' emotions as objects, not through replication or inference.
