The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Bill Belichick’s Disconnect, QB Redemption Stories, and Joe Flacco to the Bengals
Oct 8, 2025
Bill Belichick’s disconnect with players is scrutinized, revealing how personal connections impact culture. Quarterbacks like Baker and Sam Darnold find new life in the NFL when paired with the right coaches. Joe Flacco’s trade to the Bengals raises eyebrows about his fit with their struggling offense. Kickers are playing a crucial role in game outcomes, with new rules impacting strategy. The mailbag explores fan questions, from Flacco's abilities to the Steelers' defensive woes.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Relationships Still Drive College Recruiting
- John Middlekoff concludes that personal relationships still matter deeply in college recruiting despite NIL money.
- He argues Belichick's aloof personality harms recruiting and culture at UNC.
In-Person Meetings Sealed A Deal
- Middlekoff recounts flying to New York to close a near-complete deal to show face-to-face mattered.
- He uses the story to illustrate how in-person time builds trust beyond digital meetings.
Personality Matters More In College
- Belichick's lack of warmth may be acceptable in the NFL but not in college where players need mentorship.
- Middlekoff says college coaches must know players' families and backgrounds to manage young athletes' ups and downs.