Brain in a Vat Michael Huemer on Disobeying the Law
Oct 24, 2021
Michael Huemer, a philosopher known for his work in political philosophy, dives deep into the concepts of justice and law. He discusses the power of jury nullification, where juries can reject unjust laws, exemplified by the Zenger trial. Huemer contrasts justice with morality, advocating for a justice system that reflects societal intuitions. He addresses the complexities of laws, arguing for the repeal of unjust regulations like drug prohibitions, and emphasizes the importance of individual moral judgments in a fair legal system.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Jury Nullification Origin Story
- Michael Huemer recounts the John Peter Zenger trial where the jury acquitted despite the judge forbidding truth as a defense.
- He uses this to illustrate the origin of jury nullification and its role in protecting free speech.
Justice Is A Subset Of Morality
- Huemer distinguishes justice from general morality by tying justice to rights and deservedness.
- He explains many moral reasons (like charity) aren't matters of justice.
Utilitarian Outcomes Can Be Unjust
- Huemer argues utilitarianism can recommend actions that are not just, like framing an innocent person to stop riots.
- He says such outcomes abandon the language of justice.
