The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 2 - Did Vikings make a mistake with Aaron Rodgers? Greg Cosell, Super Bowl Bubble Teams
Sep 25, 2025
Veteran NFL analyst Greg Cosell joins to dissect critical quarterback performances and coaching strategies. He questions whether the Vikings missed a chance with Aaron Rodgers while breaking down Caleb Williams' growth and the Ravens' defensive issues. Cosell also highlights Sam Darnold's resurgence in Seattle, noting how their scheme enhances his play. The conversation shifts to Super Bowl contenders, with a focus on teams like the Seahawks and Chargers, and an analysis of their playoff potential and quarterback dynamics.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
PFF Grades Versus The Eye Test
- Colin observes Aaron Rodgers grades very low on PFF despite looking middle-of-the-pack on tape.
- He suggests public metrics can conflict with the eye test and context matters.
Caleb's Between-The-Numbers Test
- Greg Cosell says the key litmus test for Caleb Williams in Ben Johnson's offense is intermediate throws between the numbers.
- Consistent success there shows grasp of the offense's window throws.
Start The QB Who Wins Today
- Start the quarterback who helps you win on Sunday rather than worrying about draft capital.
- Evaluate QBs by who gives the team the best immediate chance, not past selection.