Unsolicited Advice vs Glen Scrivener || Full Debate || SLP562
Jan 20, 2025
auto_awesome
In this debate, Glen Scrivener, a Christian apologist, and Joe Folley, representing secular viewpoints, tackle whether we can be good without God. They explore complex ideas surrounding morality, arguing the relationship between secular humanism and divine teachings. The discussion also examines historical narratives' influence on ethical frameworks, contrasting perspectives on objective versus subjective morality, and the implications of evolution on moral reasoning. Listeners are invited to reflect on their own moral foundations in light of these compelling arguments.
The podcast debates whether moral values can exist without a divine source, challenging secular humanism's philosophical viability as a moral foundation.
It emphasizes that belief in moral equality may stem more from religious teachings than rational thought, particularly the idea of being created in God's image.
The speakers explore how narratives, especially Christian ones, shape moral understanding, suggesting that secular frameworks may lack the same transcendent moral authority.
Deep dives
Foundations of Morality and the Question of God
The discussion revolves around whether moral values can exist independently of a divine source. It is highlighted that many believe human rights and moral equality stem from recognition of our shared humanity, rather than solely from God. Philosophers such as Tom Holland argue that the moral intuitions we have are rooted not in self-evident truths but in biblical teachings, suggesting that our concept of morality is influenced by scriptural notions rather than being an innate human understanding. This raises questions about the credibility of secular humanism as a solid philosophical foundation for moral principles.
Equality and Its Perception
The concept of equality among individuals is scrutinized, particularly the idea that it is self-evident. The podcast contests that the belief in moral equality is derived more from religious insights, particularly the notion that all humans are created in the image of God, than from rational deduction. The discussion suggests that while contemporary society holds to the core idea of human equality, historical perspectives like those of Aristotle challenge this view by questioning the basis upon which equality can be claimed. Thus, the origin of such moral intuitions becomes a central point in understanding morality's foundations.
Moral Realism and Humanism
Both speakers examine the relationship between moral realism and the belief in God, particularly challenging the assertion that morality requires a deity for grounding. They discuss various philosophical perspectives on morality, like utilitarianism and humanism, which suggest that moral truths can exist without divine endorsement. Even though some philosophical frameworks can claim to establish objective moral truths, there remains skepticism about whether these systems can adequately reflect the values inherent in a Christian context. The conversation emphasizes that the notion of inherent rights and values often has roots tied to theological narratives and not solely secular reasoning.
The Role of Narrative in Morality
The interplay between narratives, moral principles, and ethical conclusions is explored, emphasizing how stories—whether biblical or philosophical—shape our understanding of moral values. While the speakers acknowledge the power of Christian narratives, they also assert that other philosophical traditions can offer insights into morality. Yet, it is suggested that these non-theistic frameworks may not hold the same compelling power or capacity to establish a transcendent moral order as Christianity does. This differentiates the impact of the story of Christ on moral intuitions compared to secular moral systems.
Evolution and Moral Structures
The discussion touches on the evolutionary basis of morality, questioning whether moral intuitions arise from evolutionary processes alone or if there is a divine grounding to these values. Although evolutionary perspectives suggest that moral instincts can emerge from social cooperation and survival needs, there is skepticism about whether these instincts genuinely encompass the entirety of moral truth. Pro-social behaviors may not capture the deeper ethical implications that arise from a worldview informed by love, sacrifice, and caring for the weak, as exemplified in Christian teachings. The speakers explore the divergence between a purely survival-based morality and a transformative ethical system rooted in the Christian faith.
Subscribe to the Speak Life YouTube channel for videos which see all of life with Jesus at the centre: youtube.com/SpeakLifeMedia
Subscribe to the Reformed Mythologist YouTube channel to explore how the stories we love point to the greatest story of all: youtube.com/@ReformedMythologist
Discord is an online platform where you can interact with the Speak Life team and other Speak Life supporters. There’s bonus content, creative/theological discussion and lots of fun. Join our Discord here: speaklife.org.uk/discord
Speak Life is a UK based charity that resources the church to reach the world. Learn more about us here: speaklife.org.uk