Azad Essa, "Hostile Homelands: The New Alliance Between India and Israel" (Pluto Press, 2023)
Dec 13, 2024
auto_awesome
Azad Essa, an award-winning journalist known for his work on American foreign policy and race, delves into the evolving alliance between India and Israel. He examines how India's trajectory under Modi mirrors Israel's settler-colonial practices, especially in Kashmir. The discussion covers the historical ties and ideological similarities between Hindutva and Zionism, raising concerns about democracy and minority rights. Essa also highlights the significant military cooperation between the two nations and critiques India's shifting stance on Palestine.
The India-Israel alliance under Modi represents a significant geopolitical shift marked by shared ethnonationalism and military collaboration.
Historical ties rooted in anti-colonial movements have paradoxically allowed both nations to justify their strategic support for Palestine.
Both India and Israel, while presenting democratic facades, employ repressive measures that challenge the fundamental principles of democracy and justice.
Deep dives
The Strategic Alliance of India and Israel
The growing alliance between India and Israel is highlighted as a significant geopolitical shift, particularly under Narendra Modi's leadership. This partnership transcends military cooperation, intertwining shared historical contexts, ideological similarities, and surveillance technologies. The collaboration is visibly mirrored in both nations' efforts to control and surveil minority populations, namely in Kashmir and Palestine. Both countries have utilized common political narratives that reflect their hardline security measures, reshaping the dynamics of regional power.
Historical Foundations and Ideological Parallels
The podcast delves into the historical antecedents of the India-Israel relationship, tracing back to their independence movements against colonial powers. Notably, both movements sought legitimacy from each other's struggles while concurrently supporting the rights of Palestine. The early leaders of India, such as Gandhi and Nehru, articulated anti-colonial sentiments that paradoxically supported Palestinian rights, creating a complex foundation for future relations. As both nations emerged as distinct entities, the internal and external influences led to a rhetoric that would later facilitate their strategic alignment.
Military Relationships and Technological Exchange
The military and technological ties between India and Israel are explored, emphasizing India's militaristic intrigue and dependency on Israeli arms and training. The relationship began clandestinely following India's conflicts, where Israeli expertise became pivotal to the Indian military. As the partnership formalized in the 1990s, Israeli arms and training seeped into India’s security apparatus, creating a framework that entrenches militarized policies against dissent. This exchange signifies a profound aspect of both nations' military-industrial complexes and their implications for regional security.
Democracy Versus Occupation
An examination of the paradox of democracy and occupation in India and Israel raises important questions about the nature of their governance. Both countries present themselves as democracies while simultaneously engaging in practices that undermine self-determination in occupied regions. The use of laws that grant sweeping powers to military and police forces reflects how both nations navigate the narrative of democracy, obscuring their repressive strategies against marginalized populations. This conflation challenges existing definitions of democracy, posing difficulties for scholars and activists worldwide.
Contemporary Relevance and Global Implications
The podcast rounds off by connecting the historical insights on India-Israel relations to current events and human rights violations, particularly in Gaza. The ongoing military support from India to Israel amid reported genocidal actions calls into question the moral and ethical implications of their alliance. Furthermore, the complicity of multinational corporations in these dynamics highlights a growing global concern regarding militarization and human rights. The intertwined fates of these nations emphasize the urgent need for transparency and accountability in international relations.
Under Narendra Modi, India has changed dramatically. As the world attempts to grapple with its trajectory towards authoritarianism and a 'Hindu Rashtra' (Hindu State), little attention has been paid to the linkages between Modi's India and the governments from which it has drawn inspiration, as well as military and technical support.
India once called Zionism racism, but, as Azad Essa argues, the state of Israel has increasingly become a cornerstone of India's foreign policy. Looking to replicate the 'ethnic state' in the image of Israel in policy and practice, the annexation of Kashmir increasingly resembles Israel's settler-colonial project of the occupied West Bank. The ideological and political linkages between the two states are alarming; their brands of ethnonationalism deeply intertwined.
Hostile Homelands: The New Alliance Between India and Israel (Pluto Press, 2023) puts India's relationship with Israel in its historical context, looking at the origins of Zionism and Hindutva; India's changing position on Palestine; and the countries' growing military-industrial relationship from the 1990s. Lucid and persuasive, Essa demonstrates that the India-Israel alliance spells significant consequences for democracy, the rule of law and justice worldwide.
Azad Essa is an award-winning journalist and author based between Johannesburg and New York City. He is currently a senior reporter for Middle East Eye covering American foreign policy, Islamophobia and race in the US. He is the author of The Moslems are Coming and Zuma's Bastard and has written for Al Jazeera, The Washington Post, Foreign Policy and the Guardian.
Stuti Roy has recently graduated with an MPhil in Modern South Asian Studies from the University of Oxford.