05 Democracy and Demagogues in Ancient Athens w/ Josiah Ober
Jan 9, 2017
auto_awesome
Explore democracy and demagogues in ancient Athens with historian Josiah Ober. Learn about the unique political developments, economic prosperity, and citizen participation in the Athenian system. Discover the challenges in controlling demagogues like Cleon and the fragility of democracy. Reflect on the lessons from ancient Greece for modern democratic societies.
Ancient Greece exemplified democracy as normal, contrasting with historical views.
Athenian democracy emphasized citizen involvement in decision-making processes and accountability measures like ostracism.
Deep dives
Origins of Democracy in Ancient Athens
The concept of democracy was not historically seen as desirable but became normal in modernity; ancient Greece exemplified democracy and growth as standard for citizens. The rise of democratic self-governance in other historical periods saw economic and cultural growth. The podcast explores whether our current society mirrors these historical patterns.
Athenian Democracy and Citizen Participation
Athenian democracy involved citizen self-governance through a lottery system for choosing officials, showing high citizen involvement compared to modern voting systems. Crucial decisions, including acts of war, were made by the entire citizen assembly, influencing both economic and military strength. Athenians used the ostracism institution to establish accountability and prevent demagogues from gaining too much power.
Economic Prosperity and Urbanization in Ancient Greece
Recent archaeological evidence challenges the perception of ancient Greece as economically poor, revealing significant population growth and enhanced per capita consumption. Urbanization in ancient Greece exceeded that of the Roman Empire and early modern Europe, reflecting economic development. The economic prosperity of Athenian citizens surpassed that of ancient Roman middling residents.
Lessons for Modern Democracy
Although ancient Athenian democracy had limitations such as excluding women, studying its structures and challenges remains valuable for understanding democracy as a system. The dynamic between elite politicians and the common citizens, along with mechanisms like ostracism, offers insights into the balance of power and public accountability in democratic societies. The podcast emphasizes the importance of citizen involvement to sustain a functioning democracy.
Historian Josiah Ober of Stanford University joins us for a discussion on classical Athens and how the Athenian system compared to our own democracy. As Ober writes in his recent book The Rise and Fall of Classical Greece,
“Democracy and growth define the normal...conditions of modernity: Autocracy, while still prevalent, is regarded as aberrant, so that most autocrats pretend to be democrats.... These conditions were not normal, or even imaginable, for most people through most of human history. But, for several centuries in the first millennium BCE, democracy and growth were normal for citizens in ancient Greece."
Ober's book brings together archaeological data, economic theory, and historical and demographic models in order to explain the political developments of the classical Greek world. In it, he suggests that the Ancient Greek world was historically exceptional in many of the same ways that our modern world is. If that's true, what lessons, if any, can we take away from the Athenian experience?
Don't forget to check out the web page for this episode at greecepodcast.com/5 where you can join the conversation and vote in a poll we've set up about the future of democracy.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode