Gregory Kapfhammer and Owain Parry discuss taming flaky tests in software development. They cover topics such as understanding flaky tests, common causes, handling test order dependencies, psychological impact of flaky tests on developers, and strategies for dealing with flaky tests.
Read more
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Flaky tests can introduce maintenance burdens and affect the reliability of the testing process, but tools like Datadog and Cypress offer flaky test management dashboards and insights to help developers troubleshoot and improve test reliability.
Unreliable and test order-dependent tests can undermine confidence in the testing process, but PyTest plugins like Hypothesis and Property-based tests, as well as plugins like Pytest Randomly and Pytest Picked, enable smarter test generations, reduced flakiness, and improved test ordering and selection.
Flaky test management tools like DataDog and Cypress provide dashboards and analytics to identify and prioritize flaky tests, while libraries like Tenacity and Pytest Randomly offer solutions to mitigate flakiness and improve test reliability.
Deep dives
Flaky tests and their impact on reliability
Flaky tests are test cases that pass or fail in a non-deterministic manner, even when the source code or test suite remains unchanged. The presence of flaky tests can be a challenge for developers as they can introduce maintenance burdens and affect the reliability of the testing process. Flakiness can arise due to various factors such as improper setup and teardown, shared resources, external system dependencies, and even the testing framework itself. Addressing flaky tests requires a balance between reducing flakiness and maintaining realistic and efficient tests. Tools like Datadog and Cypress offer flaky test management dashboards and insights to help developers better understand and troubleshoot flaky tests. Moreover, libraries like Tenacity and Pytest Randomly provide options for retrying tests with customized back-off strategies and randomized test ordering respectively. These tools and approaches aid in improving the overall reliability and effectiveness of the testing process.
The psychological impact and trade-offs of flaky tests
Flaky tests not only present technical challenges but also have a psychological impact on developers. Unreliable tests can undermine confidence in the testing process and result in overlooked real bugs due to a lack of trust. Test order-dependent tests, which fail or pass based on the execution sequence, often contribute to flakiness. Flaky test management requires balancing factors such as cleaning up after tests, selection of tests for execution, and the trade-offs between test reliability and execution speed. Various PyTest plugins like Hypothesis and Property-based tests enable developers to leverage smarter test generations and reduce flakiness. The use of plugins like Pytest Randomly and Pytest Picked aid in test ordering and test selection, respectively, providing insights to mitigate flakiness and improve the overall development process.
Tools and strategies to tackle flaky tests
Flaky test management tools, such as DataDog and Cypress, offer dashboards to visualize and analyze flaky tests. Such tools provide analytics, highlighting the most flaky tests and enabling developers to prioritize their efforts in resolving them. Libraries like Tenacity and Pytest Randomly offer solutions to mitigate flakiness. Tenacity provides decorators for retrying functions with customizable retry counts and back-off strategies, enabling developers to handle flaky external systems or functions. Pytest Randomly facilitates randomized test ordering, exposing interdependent tests and aiding in the identification of unintended dependencies. Effective use of these tools and strategies can lead to improved test reliability, reduced maintenance burden, and increased confidence in the testing process.
Flaky tests can lead to loss of confidence in test suite and program correctness
Flaky tests can cause developers to lose trust in the test suite and the overall correctness of their program. This can lead to developers skipping test runs, reducing the quality of both tests and code.
Mitigation and detection strategies for flaky tests
There are several strategies to mitigate and detect flaky tests. One approach is quarantining flaky tests by removing them from the critical path, but this only works if developers actively investigate and fix the issues. Running tests in parallel can expose concurrency-related flakiness. Tools like coverage.py, pytest-cov, and rough can help find coding anti-patterns that contribute to test flakiness. Additionally, libraries like libCST and fixit enable better manipulation and analysis of Python code's abstract syntax tree.