Pardon Season, And A Case Before Biden w/ Shannon Lynch
Jan 7, 2025
auto_awesome
Shannon Lynch, a podcast producer and host at the New America Foundation, joins to discuss the history and significance of presidential pardons. They delve into the controversial nature of pardons, often linked to self-serving motives, while exploring how they can also rectify historical injustices. Lynch highlights the heartbreaking case of eight wrongfully imprisoned men in Washington, D.C., emphasizing the ongoing fight for their pardons. The conversation raises vital questions about justice, accountability, and the complex dynamics surrounding wrongful convictions.
The history of presidential pardons reveals a dual purpose, sometimes correcting injustices while other times serving as political favors for the powerful.
The 8th and H case exemplifies systemic failures in the justice system, highlighting the need for pardons to rectify wrongful convictions and social reintegration challenges.
Deep dives
Understanding Presidential Pardons
Presidential pardons have a long history in the United States, rooted in constitutional authority that allows presidents to grant clemency. The podcast discusses how this power has sometimes been used for noble causes, such as correcting injustices, while other times, it resembles political favors for the wealthy or influential. Historical examples include George Washington pardoning participants in the Whiskey Rebellion and Gerald Ford pardoning Richard Nixon after Watergate. The podcast emphasizes that while pardons can serve the greater good, they also raise concerns about favoritism and inequity in the justice system.
The 8th and H Case
The 8th and H case centers on the wrongful convictions of eight young men involved in the 1984 murder of Catherine Fuller, where systemic racism and prosecutorial misconduct prevailed. These young men were coerced into false confessions without any physical evidence linking them to the crime, which the prosecutor subsequently concealed. Despite evidence suggesting an alternative suspect, the case proceeded to trial based on the false confessions, resulting in life sentences for several men. The podcast highlights how this case exemplifies the failures of the justice system and underlines the need for a presidential pardon to clear the men’s names.
The Push for Pardons
Even after their release, the six surviving men from the 8th and H case face significant barriers due to their wrongful convictions, prompting the need for a presidential pardon. The podcast discusses the broader implications of the pardon process, noting that the men struggle with job prospects, societal reintegration, and personal relationships owing to their criminal records. Advocacy through media attention and community support has been vital in pressing the Biden administration for these pardons, as public pressure can influence the decision-making process. The podcast concludes by urging listeners to participate in raising awareness and supporting the petition for the pardons, emphasizing the importance of collective action in rectifying injustices.
It's January 7th. Today, we take a look at the history of presidential pardons, which often take place at the end of an outgoing president's term. Joe Biden is expected to -- and is being pressured to -- grant a number of pardons over the next few weeks.
Jody, NIki, and Kellie are joined by Shannon Lynch of the New America Foundation to look at the history of pardons, why they are often used for what seems like self-dealing, and how they can occasionally be used to right wrongs in the justice system.
Shannon recently reported on a case in which 8 young men were incorrectly imprisoned for a murder in Washington, DC. Now, the living six men are seeking a pardon.
This Day In Esoteric Political History is a proud member of Radiotopia from PRX.
Your support helps foster independent, artist-owned podcasts and award-winning stories.
If you want to support the show directly, you can do so on our website: ThisDayPod.com
Get in touch if you have any ideas for future topics, or just want to say hello. Follow us on social @thisdaypod
Our team: Jacob Feldman, Researcher/Producer; Brittani Brown, Producer; Khawla Nakua, Transcripts; music by Teen Daze and Blue Dot Sessions; Audrey Mardavich is our Executive Producer at Radiotopia