Canadians face a pressing issue with dwindling competition, dominated by a few major corporations. From groceries to telecommunications, sectors are consolidating, raising alarms about consumer choice. Experts discuss the complexities of corporate mergers and advocate for smarter regulatory frameworks. The conversation also dives into the provincial hurdles new businesses encounter and highlights the need for collaboration to simplify market entry. Ultimately, a vision for a more inclusive competition policy aims to benefit all Canadians.
Canada's competition crisis is evident across various sectors, leading to higher prices and reduced innovation for consumers.
Recent legislative changes provide opportunities to reform competition policies, emphasizing the need for tailored strategies and broader stakeholder involvement.
Deep dives
Perceived Breakdown of Canada
Many Canadians feel that the country is broken, a sentiment echoed by various sectors such as healthcare and retail. Emergency room (ER) wait times are longer, and the grocery market is dominated by just a few corporations, leading to a perception of limited choices for consumers. A recent poll indicates that a significant majority of Canadians share this belief, highlighting feelings of frustration and stagnation. This environment sets the stage for a broader discussion about competition and the health of the nation's economy.
Lack of Competition in Various Sectors
The consolidation of industries in Canada has led to reduced competition in areas ranging from grocery retail to medical technology and even funeral services. Politicians across party lines recognize this as a growing concern that results in higher prices and decreased innovation for consumers. The podcast emphasizes that competition is deteriorating in many overlooked sectors, with examples such as the control of private insurance claims by just a couple of companies. Addressing this lack of competition is essential for fostering a healthier economic landscape.
Policy Tools for Enhancing Competition
The discussion highlights that Canada has existing tools to encourage competition and that recent legislative changes provide even greater potential for action. For instance, new measures have limited the ability for companies to justify anti-competitive behaviors through efficiency claims. There is a strong need for broader, nuanced strategies tailored to specific sectors rather than a one-size-fits-all approach. This involves considering the power dynamics involved and ensuring policies cater to not just consumers, but also workers and independent businesses.
A Hopeful Shift in Competition Policy
There is a growing consensus on the need for significant reforms in how competition policy is approached in Canada. Proposals include the establishment of more democratically driven processes that incorporate diverse voices beyond just economists and legal experts. Among the anticipated changes is the ambition for the competition bureau to effectively block mergers that stifle competition and to take action similar to initiatives in the U.S. With strong legislative changes recently enacted, the coming months are seen as a critical period for implementing meaningful competition reforms.
You've probably heard—from politicians, experts or even just friends and family—that "Canada is broken". Everyone can draw their own conclusions about that, but there's no denying some key aspects of the country aren't working well for many of us. And complaining about that is easy, it's fixing it that's the tough part. This week, The Big Story is trying to do that with Fixing Canada—a five-part series featuring deep dives into five issues that touch every Canadian, looking to experts to diagnose the problem—but most importantly, to prescribe the cure.
Today we're talking about competition. Or rather, Canada's lack of it. You may have noticed consolidation in high-profile sectors like groceries or telecommunications. But the problem goes well beyond that. Right now competition is vanishing in sectors like medical technology, funeral services and even veterinary care. How do we get it back?
Guests: Vass Bednar and Denise Hearn, authors of The Big Fix: How Companies Capture Markets and Harm Canadians, available for pre-order here
We love feedback at The Big Story, as well as suggestions for future episodes. You can find us: