Caroline Thornham, a dedicated reporter, dives into the shocking case of Nelson Replogle, a former teacher who allegedly tried to hire a hitman to kill his wife. They discuss the chilling details of the murder plot and the race against time to protect his target, Anne. Thornham reveals how Nelson's mental health deteriorated during the COVID-19 pandemic, leading to tragic choices. The podcast also explores the emotional and ethical dilemmas within domestic threats, shedding light on the impact of betrayal and loyalty among loved ones.
The podcast highlights the urgent challenge of preventing murder-for-hire plots, emphasizing the critical role of intervention by law enforcement.
It explores the complex interplay between mental health issues, particularly exacerbated by COVID-19, and the drastic behavioral changes seen in individuals like Nelson.
Deep dives
The Kill List Concept
A group operating in secret aims to prevent murders by intervening in cases listed on a dark web site known as the 'kill list.' This site allows individuals to place orders for hits on specific people using cryptocurrency. The team has successfully helped law enforcement identify and apprehend numerous individuals involved in these murder-for-hire plots, amassing a daunting tally of several hundred targets. The series investigates the impact of the kill list on the victims, exploring the profound implications surrounding their lives and the motivations of those plotting against them.
Anne Replogle's Critical Situation
The case revolves around Anne Replogle, a retired teacher whose life is threatened by an individual named Boniface, who has plotted her murder. As the team learns of this imminent danger, they rush to alert law enforcement in hopes of preventing the attack before Anne embarks on her journey to the animal hospital. The urgency is heightened by the fear that Boniface, someone potentially very close to Anne, could become aware of the intervention. This moral dilemma presents a challenge, as approaching Anne directly may not only panicking Boniface but endanger Anne's life further.
The Arrest of Nelson Replogle
As the investigation unfolds, it becomes clear that Anne's husband, Nelson Replogle, is implicated in the murder plot against her. Evidence collected through cryptocurrency transactions points to Nelson as the individual who attempted to hire someone to carry out the hit. Consequently, law enforcement apprehends Nelson, raising questions about his motivations and mental state leading to this shocking accusation. This shift in focus transforms the case from a traditional whodunit to exploring the deeper implications behind Nelson's actions and the reasons that led a seemingly devoted husband to attempt to harm his wife.
The Impact of COVID-19 on Mental Health
Nelson's mental health plays a pivotal role in understanding his actions, particularly in relation to the psychological effects of COVID-19, which he contracted before attempting to have Anne killed. Reports suggest that the virus may have triggered a bipolar disorder episode in Nelson, fundamentally altering his personality and behaviors. Family members have expressed their belief that the pandemic significantly changed Nelson, leading him to engage in erratic and dangerous behavior, including infidelities and bizarre obsessions. The ensuing legal discussions focus not only on his culpability but also on the implications of mental health as a crucial factor in his actions, ultimately influencing the court's sentencing.
Someone, going by the alias Boniface, wants a retired school teacher in Knoxville Tennessee dead. But the same day that Carl and team discover the kill order, is the day the murder is supposed to happen.
Follow the Kill List on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. You can binge all episodes early and ad-free on Wondery+. Join Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting www.wondery.com/links/kill-list now.