Selena Simmons-Duffin, health policy correspondent at NPR, discusses the legal challenges faced by women seeking abortions in Texas, the complex landscape of abortion laws in the state, and contradictions in the Texas Supreme Court's opinions. The podcast also includes an interview with Simmons-Duffin and closing remarks from the host.
Texas' restrictive abortion laws prioritize the life of the pregnant person over their fertility, disregarding the potential long-term impact on their reproductive health.
Unclear requirements and potential legal consequences under Texas' abortion laws create immense pressure on doctors, making access to abortion care more complicated and restrictive.
Deep dives
Kate Cox's fight for abortion rights
Kate Cox, a woman in Texas, found herself in a devastating situation when she discovered her fetus had a serious genetic condition. Wanting an abortion, she faced the harsh reality of Texas' restrictive abortion laws, which only allow the procedure if the pregnant person's life is at risk. Cox sued the state, hoping for an exemption, but the Texas Supreme Court ruled against her, stating that the risk to her fertility was not sufficient. The case highlights the difficulties faced by individuals trying to navigate the complex legal landscape of abortion restrictions and the impact it has on their lives.
The impossible situation for doctors
Texas doctors find themselves in an impossible situation when it comes to providing abortions. The state's abortion laws leave the determination of whether a patient qualifies for the limited medical exemption solely up to the doctor's judgment. However, this puts doctors at risk of facing legal consequences if their judgment is found to be unreasonable, making them vulnerable to malpractice suits and potential harm to their medical licenses. The unclear requirements and high stakes create immense pressure on doctors and further complicate access to abortion care.
The impact of Texas' abortion bans
Texas' strict abortion laws have far-reaching consequences, not just for the individuals seeking abortions, but also for doctors, hospitals, and reproductive rights advocacy groups. The laws not only ban abortions with limited exceptions but also allow private citizens to sue anyone involved in the abortion process. This creates a chilling effect, forcing doctors to err on the side of caution and hospitals to deny necessary care. The lack of clarity and the severe penalties associated with providing or seeking abortions further restricts access to reproductive healthcare in Texas.
Kate Cox’s fight to abort her pregnancy and save her fertility in Texas says a lot about America’s post-Roe, fractured approach to reproductive rights.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get benefits like zero ads on any Slate podcast, bonus episodes of shows like Slow Burn and Dear Prudence—and you’ll be supporting the work we do here on What Next. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to help support our work.