Pints With Aquinas The Truth, Reality, and Conspiracy Theories (Joe Heschmeyer) | Ep. 553
Nov 21, 2025
Joe Heschmeyer, an author and Catholic apologist, dives deep into the nature of truth, reality, and conspiracy theories. He examines how emotional comfort fosters the spread of conspiracy theories and discusses the erosion of trust in science during COVID. Joe also tackles the complexities of knowledge limits and faith, asserting that belief often requires willful assent. They reflect on societal polarization, the appeal of monoculture, and the moral intricacies surrounding current geopolitical conflicts. It’s a thought-provoking exploration of modern skepticism and faith.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Set A Threshold And Act
- When overwhelmed by information, set a reasonable threshold for action and stop gathering infinite data.
- Decide core questions (e.g., 'Is Jesus who he says he is?') and act once you have sufficient evidence.
Too Much Choice Drives Paralysis
- Paradox of choice and information overload create analysis paralysis and radical skepticism.
- More options or data often reduce decision quality rather than improve it.
Pull People Out Of The Rabbit Hole
- To persuade someone deep in conspiracies, bring them back into ordinary life and alternative ways of arranging facts.
- Build personal relationships and shared experiences rather than trying to out-debate them on their theory.
