Michael Albertus, "Land Power: Who Has It, Who Doesn't, and How That Determines the Fate of Societies" (Basic Books, 2025)
Feb 11, 2025
auto_awesome
Michael Albertus, a political science professor at the University of Chicago and author of several influential books, discusses the profound impact of land ownership on societal structures. He illustrates how historical land reallocations have shaped inequality, oppression, and even environmental crises. Albertus highlights colonial histories, the dynamics of land power in different cultures, and how contemporary issues, like climate change, demand urgent reforms in land rights. Understanding these factors could redefine societal futures.
Land ownership profoundly influences societal structures, determining inequalities and life opportunities as illustrated by contrasting experiences in Peru.
The historical and ongoing Great Reshuffle of land ownership highlights its role in redefining social hierarchies and community dynamics across various societies.
Deep dives
The Foundation of Land Power
Land serves as a critical foundation for political, economic, and social structures within societies. Its ownership can greatly influence the life trajectories of individuals, as demonstrated through contrasting case studies from Peru, highlighting a woman bound to servitude and a senator benefiting from land policies. The stark differences in their experiences underline how the dynamics of land ownership not only dictate subsistence but also shape broader societal inequalities. This exploration emphasizes that land is far more than a mere resource; it shapes identities and life opportunities throughout human history.
The Great Reshuffle and Its Implications
The past two centuries have witnessed significant upheaval in land ownership, referred to as the Great Reshuffle, driven by factors such as population growth, state-making, and social conflict. This concept encompasses various land reallocation processes that involve transferring land from one group to another, often resulting in violence, as seen during the French Revolution or in China post-World War II. The reshuffling process can take many forms, including settler reforms and collective land ownership, highlighting the complex relationships between land and power across different societies. The implications of these transfers are profound, as they can redefine social hierarchies and alter the fabric of communities worldwide.
Colonialism and the Impact on Indigenous Peoples
Colonial practices have historically led to the appropriation of land from indigenous populations, resulting in lasting impacts on societal structures and inequalities. The processes of colonization not only disregarded existing relationships between the land and indigenous people but also imposed new landholding systems that further marginalized these communities. Examples from the United States exemplify how the Dominion Lands Act and other policies facilitated dispossession and the creation of racial hierarchies. These ongoing issues highlight the need for recognition and reparation, emphasizing that the consequences of land policies are still felt in contemporary society.
Contemporary Land Power and Future Considerations
In the modern context, land remains a vital asset, influencing economic, social, and environmental dynamics, including the implications of climate change. Rising sea levels and natural disasters are pushing populations inland, reshaping land markets and leading to new patterns of ownership and investment. As billionaires increasingly acquire farmland, the challenge lies in using land power responsibly to address historical injustices and empower marginalized communities. The potential for land to drive positive change—through environmental conservation, gender equity in ownership, and development initiatives—highlights its enduring significance in shaping the future.
For millennia, land has been a symbol of wealth and privilege. But the true power of land ownership is even greater than we might think. InLand Power: Who Has It, Who Doesn't, and How That Determines the Fate of Societies(Basic Books, 2025), political scientist Michael Albertus shows that who owns the land determines whether a society will be equal or unequal, whether it will develop or decline, and whether it will safeguard or sacrifice its environment.
Modern history has been defined by land reallocation on a massive scale. From the 1500s on, European colonial powers and new nation-states shifted indigenous lands into the hands of settlers. The 1900s brought new waves of land appropriation, from Soviet and Maoist collectivization to initiatives turning large estates over to family farmers. The shuffle continues today as governments vie for power and prosperity by choosing who should get land. Drawing on a career’s worth of original research and on-the-ground fieldwork, Albertus shows that choices about who owns the land have locked in poverty, sexism, racism, and climate crisis—and that what we do with the land today can change our collective fate.
Michael Albertus is professor of political science at the University of Chicago. The author of four previous books, his writing has appeared in the New York Times, Washington Post, Atlantic, Foreign Affairs, and elsewhere. He lives in Chicago, Illinois.