Revived Thoughts

Revived Conversation: Church Discipline

10 snips
Sep 24, 2026
A lively discussion explores why church discipline seems so rare today and how its practice has changed across church history. The conversation visits Reformation-era structure, Puritan traditions, revival leaders, congregational accountability, and the tension between biblical responsibility and seeker-sensitive pragmatism. It also considers restorative correction, pastoral relationships, and why churches hesitate to confront serious problems.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

The Pastor Who Resigned Behind The Red Door

  • Troy Angel recalls visiting a church where the pastor abruptly resigned after an awkward sermon and visibly uncomfortable elders stood behind him.
  • The unexplained scandal became memorable because the guests only knew the pastor’s final sermon title, “Behind the Red Door.”
INSIGHT

Large Churches Struggle To Know Their Sheep

  • Church discipline becomes harder to practice as congregations grow because pastors may not know members personally enough to shepherd them well.
  • Troy Angel argues that many churches now function more like corporate PR or HR departments during scandals than communities applying Matthew 18.
INSIGHT

Church Discipline Mostly Disappeared From Mainstream Practice

  • The hosts observe that church discipline is widely absent today, even where church bylaws technically preserve a process.
  • Joel notes that some smaller Bible-preaching churches still teach and practice it, including addressing members living together outside marriage.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app