Join Jenny Guimant, a math teacher from Indianapolis, Angela Fleck, a sixth-grade social studies teacher in Spokane, and Adam Swinyard, Superintendent of Spokane Public Schools, as they dive into the complexities of smartphone bans in schools. They share real classroom experiences, highlighting the improvements in student engagement and social interactions. The discussion also touches on the challenges teachers face with policy enforcement, the shift towards alternative technology for learning, and how to promote extracurricular activities as a healthy distraction from screens.
The implementation of smartphone bans in classrooms has led to increased student engagement and a more focused learning environment.
Teachers are adapting their management strategies to facilitate better in-person communication and reduce the negative social impacts of social media.
Deep dives
Impact of Smartphone Distractions in Classrooms
Smartphones have become a significant source of distraction in classrooms, where students often focus more on their devices than on lessons. Teachers report that students engage in activities like scrolling social media, taking selfies, or watching videos instead of participating in class. This distraction not only hampers learning but also contributes to a chaotic classroom environment, making it difficult for teachers to maintain attention. The teachers described feelings of frustration as their efforts to teach were continuously interrupted by students' preoccupation with their phones.
Statewide Smartphone Bans and Their Effects
The introduction of statewide bans on smartphones during instructional time has led to a noticeable improvement in classroom dynamics. With the absence of phones, teachers report heightened student engagement and a reduction in disruptive behavior. This newfound authority to enforce the ban has benefitted both teaching effectiveness and overall school culture. As students become less distracted, it has also contributed to reducing interpersonal issues that often arise from social media interactions during school hours.
Adjustments in Classroom Management Strategies
Teachers have adapted their classroom management strategies in response to the smartphone ban, finding that students are now more attentive and engaged during lessons. By eliminating phones, teachers report a significant increase in students’ understanding of assignments and a decrease in drama that typically results from social media interactions. The focus has shifted to fostering in-person communication and social interaction among students, which is vital for their development. While some teachers miss the convenience of technology for specific tasks, they acknowledge that the overall benefits of reduced distractions outweigh these drawbacks.
Fostering Healthy Relationships with Technology
Educational leaders stress the importance of teaching students to develop a healthy relationship with technology while maintaining the benefits of connectivity. The goal is not to vilify smartphones, but rather to encourage appropriate usage that prioritizes in-person interactions and wellbeing. Initiatives promoting extracurricular activities are also implemented to engage students outside of screens, aiming to redirect their focus towards more active and fulfilling experiences. This holistic approach seeks to reduce addiction-like behavior towards devices while helping students learn to manage their time and attention effectively.
Many school districts and states have enacted new restrictions on smartphones in classrooms during instructional time, in the name of increasing student engagement and counteracting the negative effects that social media has on youth mental health. We checked in with two teachers and an administrator to hear how the new rules are playing out.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode