Historian Prof Benjamin Reiss and comedian Desiree Burch join host Greg Jenner to explore the life and controversial career of showman P.T. Barnum. Unraveling his illusions and exploitative exhibitions, they discuss his hoaxes, acquisition of Scudder's American Museum, hiring of General Tom Thumb, failed bid for Shakespeare's house, investment in building his mansion, and recruitment of opera singer Jenny Lind.
P.T. Barnum was a master of hoaxes and believed that as long as people felt they were getting value for their money, it was not fraud, showcasing his affinity for deception and entertainment.
Despite his fame and success, P.T. Barnum's shows and exhibits often relied on racism and exploitation of marginalized individuals, perpetuating harmful stereotypes and profiting from the suffering of others.
Deep dives
Benjamin Reese discusses P.T. Barnum's career of hoaxes and humbugs
Benjamin Reese, an expert on 19th century American literature, describes P.T. Barnum's affinity for hoaxes, which he referred to as humbugs. Barnum believed that a good hoax should be entertaining for everyone involved and argued that as long as people still felt they were getting value for their money, it was not fraud. Reese also discusses Barnum's early life, from selling sweets as a child to setting up lotteries, and his various businesses and ventures. He discusses Barnum's first controversial exhibit, Joyce Heth, an enslaved, disabled woman who was exhibited as the nursemaid to George Washington. Reese highlights the exploitative and dehumanizing treatment Heth endured during her exhibition. He also mentions other examples of Barnum's questionable exhibits, such as a microcephalic black man presented as a wild beast. Despite Barnum's fame and success in the entertainment industry, he was marred by racism and his penchant for turning people's disabilities into public spectacle.
The story of P.T. Barnum's famous performer, General Tom Thumb
The podcast delves into the story of Charles Stratton, known as General Tom Thumb, who was one of Barnum's most famous performers. Stratton had congenital dwarfism and was only about 25 inches tall. Barnum hired him as a human oddity for his museum and presented him as a folk character from England named Tom Thumb. Stratton's exhibitions became hugely popular, attracting hundreds of thousands of spectators. He even toured England and performed in front of Queen Victoria. Despite Barnum's exploitation of Stratton's physical condition, Stratton's performances fueled Barnum's success and wealth.
The controversies surrounding Barnum's treatment of his exhibits
The podcast highlights the problematic and exploitative aspects of Barnum's shows and exhibits. It discusses the case of Madame Clofolia, a bearded lady who was exhibited and subjected to examinations to prove she was a woman. Barnum also displayed a microcephalic black man named William Henry Johnson, presenting him as a curiously constructed automaton and perpetuating harmful racial stereotypes. The podcast also reveals Barnum's acquisition of Jumbo the elephant, which upset Queen Victoria and led to public safety demonstrations across the Brooklyn Bridge. The episode emphasizes that while Barnum brought joy and laughter to many, his methods often relied on racism and exploitation of marginalized individuals.
Jonathan Pie reflects on P.T. Barnum's legacy
Jonathan Pie, the host of the podcast, acknowledges Barnum's skills as an entertainer and showman, bringing joy to people's lives through his spectacles. However, Pie emphasizes the racist and exploitative aspects of Barnum's career, pointing out that Barnum frequently exhibited non-white performers as objects of curiosity and portrayed them through degrading and stereotypical lenses. He critiques the film 'The Greatest Showman' for downplaying or erasing Barnum's problematic actions, allowing his legacy to persist as that of a champion of the dispossessed, when in reality, he perpetuated white supremacy and profited off of racism.
Greg Jenner is joined by historian Prof Benjamin Reiss and comedian Desiree Burch in 19th-century America to meet the self-proclaimed showman, P.T. Barnum. He was a man famous for his museums and shows as well as "curiosities" such as General Tom Thumb, Bearded Ladies and The Fiji Mermaid. But look beyond Barnum’s infamous spin and you’ll find that contrary to his pop culture image this showman was far from the greatest.
For the full-length version of this episode, please look further back in the feed.
Produced by Cornelius Mendez
Script by Greg Jenner and Emma Nagouse
Research by Charlotte Potter
A production by The Athletic for BBC Radio 4.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode