News Meeting: Why Kamala Harris’s bet on abortion rights didn’t pay off and mass deportations
Nov 8, 2024
auto_awesome
David Rhodes, Executive chairman of Sky News, shares his insights on the aftermath of the US elections. David Taylor, a Tortoise contributing editor, discusses Trump's potential policies and promises regarding mass deportations. Katie Riley, Tortoise's data editor, highlights the grim impacts of abortion bans and voter paradoxes. They explore the misalignment between voter sentiment and election outcomes, questioning the effectiveness of media strategies on reproductive rights and the haunting legacy of Trump’s political ambitions.
The podcast emphasizes the critical disconnect between voter perceptions of abortion rights and the real implications of supporting candidates like Trump.
Journalists are urged to move beyond mere reporting to critically analyze political narratives and the societal impacts of policies.
Deep dives
The Journey of Investigative Reporting
The podcast reflects on the evolution of investigative reporting over its five-year run, emphasizing the commitment to uncovering injustices. The hosts share their gratitude for listener support and highlight their dedication to telling gripping stories that resonate with human experiences, often framed as love stories despite the darkness they may address. Throughout this time, significant legal victories have been achieved, showcasing the power of journalism to challenge the status quo and facilitate meaningful change. The hosts express a renewed commitment to continuing their efforts and connection with their audience as they look forward to future projects.
Understanding Voter Dynamics in 2024
A central focus emerges around the shifting dynamics of the American electorate leading up to the 2024 elections, contrasting it with the 2016 experience. Unlike previous elections, voters made more decisive choices, indicating that a majority sought policies aligned with Trump's proposals rather than merely his personality. This user's choice reflects a deeper understanding of priorities that resonated with voters, driving them to support candidates that promised specific changes. Journalists emphasize the importance of contextualizing voting patterns to capture the nuanced motivations behind electoral decisions.
The Reality of Abortion Access
Abortion access is presented as a critical issue, highlighting the disconnect between voter perceptions and the implications of electing Donald Trump. Many voters, despite endorsing measures to protect abortion rights at the state level, still supported Trump, indicating a misunderstanding of the consequences of their choices. The podcast details the risk associated with limiting abortion access and the potential dangers women may face as a result of future policies enacted under Trump's administration. As the conversation unfolds, the disconnect between voter intentions and political realities is underscored, prompting further reflection on how to communicate these issues effectively.
The Importance of Journalistic Integrity
The podcast delves into the responsibility of journalists to scrutinize and challenge political narratives, especially those surrounding controversial policies like immigration and abortion. It argues against the notion that journalism should simply report without critical analysis, emphasizing the need to investigate the feasibility and implications of political pledges. As key figures in the discussion explain, the job of reporters goes beyond tracing statements; it involves demanding accountability and thoroughly understanding the realities behind political promises. This highlights the importance of nuanced reporting that informs the public about potential societal impacts of government policies.
Giles Whittell and guests debate what should lead the news following the US election. They discuss Donald Trump’s plans for day one of his next presidency, women dying as a result of abortion bans and the role the media had in a Republican victory.
Guests:
David Rhodes, executive chairman of Sky News
David Taylor, contributing editor at Tortoise
Katie Riley, Tortoise’s data editor
Host: Giles Whittell, deputy editor at Tortoise.
Email: newsmeeting@tortoisemedia.com
Producer: Casey Magloire
Executive producer: Rebecca Moore
To find out more about Tortoise:
- Download the Tortoise app - for a listening experience curated by our journalists
- Subscribe to Tortoise+ on Apple Podcasts for early access and exclusive content
- Become a member and get access to all of Tortoise's premium audio offerings and more
If you want to get in touch with us directly about a story, or tell us more about the stories you want to hear about contact hello@tortoisemedia.com