

Payton’s Place? Ranking the Top NFL Coaches, GMs and More
May 14, 2025
Mina is joined by Kevin Clark, an NFL writer for The Ringer and ESPN, known for his insightful analysis. They kick off with a lively debate on their top 10 NFL coaches, spotlighting Mike Tomlin and Kyle Shanahan. The duo dives into coaching dynamics, exploring how injuries and adaptability affect team success. They also rank front offices and discuss passionate fan bases, revealing the unique cultures surrounding teams like the 49ers and Falcons. The conversation navigates the evolving coaching landscape and the complex relationships between teams and their supporters.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Tomlin vs. Shanahan Strengths
- Mike Tomlin consistently wins games with diminishing rosters, showcasing strong roster management and motivation skills.
- Kyle Shanahan excels at coaching quarterbacks, evidenced by impressive yards per attempt stats for his players.
Harbaugh's Adaptability and Success
- John Harbaugh deserves credit for adapting the Ravens' offense to suit Lamar Jackson's unique play style.
- His decision to hire complementary coordinators and build a top defense underlines his coaching success.
Dan Campbell's Lions Turnaround
- Dan Campbell transformed the Detroit Lions from a struggling franchise into a competitive team with strong culture and resilience.
- His fearless leadership and ability to empower staff and players speaks volumes about his coaching.