

Episode 275: An LGBT Book Prize Goes Poof
21 snips Sep 8, 2025
This week, the hosts dive into the fallout from the cancellation of the Polari Prize amid controversies surrounding trans representation. They discuss John Boyne's provocative works and the implications for Holocaust education. The debate around 'own voices' in literature raises questions about who gets to tell certain stories. Also featured are the legal ramifications of free speech in the LGBTQ+ discourse and the challenges of navigating identity politics in today's cultural landscape. Humor and serious issues intertwine as they unpack these complex conversations.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Controversial Holocaust Novel Backlash
- John Boyne wrote The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, a hugely popular 2006 novel often used in classrooms about a Nazi's son befriending a Jewish prisoner.
- Historians and educators criticized it for inaccuracies and for misleading readers about the Holocaust.
Trans YA Novel Sparks Online Pile-On
- In 2019 Boyne published My Brother's Name Is Jessica, a YA novel about a boy whose sibling transitions to female, intended as an ally work.
- The book drew heavy online criticism for perspective, title framing, and perceived centering of cis experiences.
Limits Of Strict #OwnVoices Rules
- The hosts explain the #ownvoices movement morphed into a stricter norm that some saw as forbidding outsiders from writing certain identities.
- Jesse argues rigid, essentialist limits on who may tell which stories can be counterproductive.