Lydia Saad, Director of U.S. social research at Gallup, and Mark Krikorian, Executive Director of the Center for Immigration Studies, dive deep into America's complex immigration landscape. They discuss how public opinion reflects growing support for immigration yet labels it as a divisive issue. The conversation covers the challenges of balancing compassion with effective immigration management under the current administration, alongside contrasting policy perspectives. The duo explores the historical context of immigration reform and the implications of rising nativism.
Americans have contradictory views on immigration, being supportive yet considering it the most divisive issue.
Polarization between Republicans and Democrats reflects contrasting perspectives on immigration's economic impact and benefits.
Deep dives
Donald Trump's Focus on Immigration
Former President Donald Trump consistently emphasizes immigration issues, promising mass deportations, advocating an end to birthright citizenship for those here unlawfully, and proposing to deny entry based on migrants' ideological beliefs. In contrast, President Biden's stance has evolved from an initial humane approach to proposing border closures and asylum suspension in response to record-high illegal border crossings.
Reforming Immigration Policies
Public perception towards immigration has shifted over the years. While Americans overall view immigration positively, concerns arise predominantly around illegal immigration and chaotic border situations. Previous attempts at immigration reform, such as in 1996, aimed at tightening enforcement measures and limiting avenues for unauthorized immigrants to attain legal status.
Divergent Immigration Policies and Political Polarization
The polarization around immigration policies is evident between Republicans, who generally view immigration negatively for its economic impact, and Democrats, who see it as beneficial. Despite bipartisan efforts, comprehensive immigration reform has repeatedly faced challenges, with recent administrations' approaches reflecting contrasting strategies and struggles in striking a balance on immigration issues.
Americans hold contradictory views on immigration: They’re more supportive of it than ever before, while also calling it the nation’s most divisive political issue. A pollster, a policy researcher, and a pundit help make sense of our stalled immigration debate.
This episode was produced by Hady Mawajdeh, edited by Matt Collette, fact-checked by Laura Bullard, engineered by Patrick Boyd and Andrea Kristinsdottir, and hosted by Sean Rameswaram.