Bulwark Takes The Republicans' BIG LIE on Health Care
Oct 1, 2025
The podcast tackles the misleading claim that Democrats aim to provide free healthcare for undocumented immigrants during the government shutdown. Jonathan Cohn debunks this myth, revealing that undocumented individuals are largely barred from major federal healthcare programs. He underscores the real debate surrounding healthcare funding, primarily affecting U.S. citizens, and critiques Republicans for avoiding genuine discussions about healthcare policy. The episode also explores the bipartisan roots of emergency Medicaid and why it remains vital for all communities.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Why This Is A 'Big Lie'
- Jonathan Cohn labels the GOP claim a 'big lie' because it is fundamentally false and verifiable.
- He reserves 'lie' for claims that are demonstrably untrue and told by those who should know better.
Shutdown Stakes: Health Provisions On The Table
- Republicans control the White House and Congress but lack votes to pass a spending bill without Democrats.
- Democrats demand undoing Medicaid cuts and extending ACA subsidies for 20+ million people as bargaining conditions.
Why Republicans Avoid A Health Debate
- Polls show voters trust Democrats more on health care, making this a messaging risk for Republicans.
- Republicans avoid debating the substance because undoing coverage and subsidies is unpopular with voters.