Kyle Chayka, a staff writer for The New Yorker and author of "Filter World," delves into intriguing issues surrounding technology and its impact on society. He discusses Trump's outrageous $5 million 'gold card' proposal for citizenship, exploring its implications for immigration and economic policies. Chayka also draws parallels between modern technocrats and the fascists of 1930s Japan, raising concerns about power dynamics in governance. Additionally, the episode highlights the absurdity of consumer fears around black plastic utensils stemming from a simple math error.
Trump's proposal for selling citizenship gold cards highlights troubling economic assumptions that may further erode public trust in governance.
The emergence of tech-driven governance raises critical questions about the balance between technological advancement and the preservation of democratic values.
Deep dives
The Impact of Economic Messaging
Recent statements from the Trump administration regarding the state of the economy, particularly from Treasury Secretary Scott Besson, claim that the entire private sector is in a recession. However, this assertion lacks credibility and is challenged by the actual economic indicators. Moreover, President Trump's proposal to sell gold cards for $5 million each is presented in a mathematically intriguing manner, suggesting significant revenue generation without grounding it in reality. The podcast highlights the disparity between such grand announcements and the actual capacity of the government and economy, stressing how such messaging can foster public distrust.
The Role of Technocrats in Governance
The discussion delves into the emergence of technocrats in government, drawing parallels to historical contexts like Japan in the 1930s. The shift from technocrats focusing on public welfare to those pushing private sector agendas is highlighted, particularly with figures from Silicon Valley influencing national policy. This transition reflects a concerning trend where the fidelity to governmental ideals is replaced by an unwavering allegiance to technology and innovation, potentially at the expense of democratic values. The implications of this shift raise questions about the direction of governance and public accountability in a tech-driven era.
Cultural Perceptions and Market Reactions
The podcast references a significant public response to a study on the safety of black plastic spatulas, which initially claimed they were dangerous due to leaching harmful substances. A subsequent examination revealed a critical math error in the study, leading to the conclusion that black spatulas are safe to use. Despite this clarification, consumer behavior was influenced as sales of black plastic utensils dropped dramatically, revealing how misinformation can shape market dynamics. This incident illustrates the power of media narratives and how a single flawed piece of research can disrupt consumer trust and behavior.
Technological Innovation vs. Human Value
The podcast emphasizes the tension between technological advancement and human values within the context of governance and societal needs. The conversation critiques the idea that technology should be prioritized over public good, underscoring a moral imperative to consider the impact of technology on society. By referencing the historical trajectory of technocrats and their influences, it suggests that an unchecked focus on technological solutions can lead to dehumanization and authoritarianism. The discussion culminates in a call for a balanced approach that recognizes the importance of human considerations in technological progress and governance.
This week: Trump has proposed a $5 million “gold card” for US citizenship, suggesting that the US could sell 10 million of them to pay off the national debt. Felix Salmon, Emily Peck, and Elizabeth Spiers discuss the logic behind this considering the similar programs that already exist and the possible pool of candidates. Then, they discuss guest Kyle Chayka’s recent piece in the New Yorker comparing Silicon Valley invasion of the government, led by Elon Musk, to the “techno-fasiscts” of 1930s Japan. And finally, the danger of black plastic kitchen utensils was debunked after the discovery of a simple math error. But the “zombie fact” is still affecting sales.
In the Slate Plus episode: The $19 Strawberry and Rise of Luxury Food
Want to hear that discussion and hear more Slate Money? Join Slate Plus to unlock weekly bonus episodes. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the Slate Money show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/moneyplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Jessamine Molli and Cheyna Roth.