Why the West Wants to Bring Down the New Syrian State - with Sami Hamdi (Part 2)
Jan 3, 2025
auto_awesome
Sami Hamdi, an expert on Middle Eastern politics, dives into the complexities of the Syrian conflict. He discusses the future of the new Syrian government and the delicate balancing act of addressing minority concerns while navigating foreign pressures. The conversation highlights Turkey's evolving role in the revolution and critiques Western hypocrisy on women's rights in relation to Syrian governance. Hamdi also emphasizes the historical context of Islam in state politics and the need for an authentic Syrian path to stability amidst global anxieties.
Ahmad al-Shara's government is working to reassure minorities by emphasizing rights protection and celebrating diverse cultural practices to foster inclusivity.
The new Syrian leadership faces the challenge of balancing Islamic governance with Western interests while avoiding historical pitfalls of past regimes.
Navigating sectarian complexities and foreign geopolitical interests is essential for maintaining national unity and addressing the fears of Syrian citizens.
Lessons from other nations highlight the importance of fully understanding the population's needs to avoid alienation and instability in governance.
Deep dives
The Dynamics of the Syrian Government
The new Syrian government, led by Ahmad al-Shara, has made significant efforts to reassure minority groups within Syria, notably the Alawis and Christians, of their rights and safety under its leadership. This focus stems from the historical tensions and anxieties that these minorities faced during the Assad regime, and the new leadership seeks to build a sense of security by emphasizing inclusivity and protection. Ahmad al-Shara's government has adopted measures like publicly celebrating Christmas and protecting religious shrines to signal its commitment to safeguarding minority interests. This approach is reflective of a broader strategy to unify diverse factions and mitigate external pressures that may exploit inter-communal fears against the backdrop of a shifting political landscape.
Western Influence and Its Implications
There is a significant concern regarding the influence of Western powers on the new Syrian government, particularly in how those powers have historically acted against Islamic governance. As the government navigates both local dynamics and international relations, it faces the challenge of balancing appeasement to Western interests with adherence to its Islamic identity. The pressure to minimize the role of Islam in governance is palpable, as past regimes faced severe backlash for attempts to Islamicize their policies, complicating any move towards a more pronounced Islamic mandate. The fear of economic sanctions or military intervention looms large, making it crucial for the Syrian leadership to deftly manage both domestic aspirations and external expectations.
The Role of Religion in Governance
Ahmad al-Shara's government is grappling with the question of how prominently to feature Islamic principles within governance, a crucial issue for a predominantly Muslim populace. Lessons from neighboring nations indicate a delicate balance is necessary; the Historical precedence of diminishing Islam's role has led to political backlash and instability. A crucial aspect of the new government's legitimacy hinges on its ability to resonate with the sentiments of the majority while addressing the fears of minority groups. As the government contemplates its Constitutional framework, it must consider whether to reinforce a Sharia-influenced governance model or adopt secular pluralism to appease foreign powers.
Challenges of Sectarian and International Tensions
Navigating the sectarian complexities within Syria is compounded by the geopolitical interests of international actors, notably Turkey, the UAE, and the US. Each of these players has its agenda that influences the dynamics of Syrian politics, from supporting opposition factions to stifling Islamic rhetoric in governance. The fear of exploitation of sectarian divisions by foreign actors is a pressing concern; Ahmad al-Shara's government is attempting to forge a consensus among the disparate factions while countering external meddling. This delicate balance is vital for sustaining national unity and ensuring the government can effectively counteract influence that seeks to exploit Syrian society's vulnerabilities.
Historical Context and Lessons from the Past
Reflections on the historical experiences of countries like Tunisia and Sudan are essential in understanding the trajectory of Syria's new leadership. Previous leaders in these regions found themselves trapped between appeasing foreign powers and responding to local demands, ultimately leading to their failures and political turmoil. The cautionary tales suggest that a government that fails to ground itself in a genuine understanding of its population's needs, particularly regarding their religious and cultural identity, risks alienation and instability. The Syrian government is tasked with drawing lessons from these regional experiences to establish a system that secures both the majority’s rights and the minorities’ concerns while resisting the pull of foreign dominance.
Turkey's Influence and Its Significance
Turkey's role has been pivotal in shaping the new political landscape of Syria, particularly as Ahmad al-Shara seeks to navigate his government’s international relationships. Turkey's historical support for Syrian opposition groups has positioned it as a potential ally for the new government, yet this comes with its implications and conditions. The dynamic relationship between Turkey and the fledgling Syrian government must be managed carefully; reliance on Turkish support could complicate internal policies and regional alliances. The government’s ability to maintain its independence while leveraging Turkey's influence for national stability will be critical in securing its position both domestically and internationally.
Expectations from the New Government
The success of Ahmad al-Shara's government will depend heavily on its capacity to meet the diverse expectations of the Syrian populace while navigating substantial external pressures. Many citizens hope for a government that promotes religious identity alongside stability and prosperity, while others fear the potential for a return to authoritarian practices reminiscent of the Assad regime. A clear and committed vision that aligns with the populace's aspirations, particularly in terms of rights and representation of Islam in governance, is essential for maintaining legitimacy and popular support. As such, the government must focus on building trust through tangible improvements in governance, social cohesion, and inclusivity to sustainably propel Syria towards a hopeful future.
In this second session of our 2024 roundup we have Sami Hamdi back on the show to discuss Syria in more detail. Syria is in many ways a ray of hope but also raises all sorts of uncertainties. What path will the revolution take? How do we assess Jolani and the rebel movement? What of the demands of regional and global actors, ideological and otherwise. And how does Syria navigate the US and Israel's anxieties about the new government and its Islamic colour.
Become a member to ger access to exclusive monthly calls: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/membership
You can also support The Thinking Muslim through a one-time donation: https://www.thinkingmuslim.com/Donate
