Bulwark Takes RFK’s Deep Thoughts on...Circumcision?
Oct 10, 2025
In a surprising cabinet meeting, RFK Jr. suggests a link between circumcision and autism, citing dubious studies. The hosts dissect the pseudoscience behind his claim and the problematic reactions from cabinet members. They highlight earlier mixed messaging on Tylenol from the administration, critiquing RFK's misleading examples from Cuba and the Amish. Medical experts push back against his assertions, emphasizing the importance of evidence-based health policy. The discussion wraps up with warnings to consult professionals and avoid misinformation.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Tentative Studies Framed As Certainty
- RFK Jr. cited two studies and suggested early circumcision correlates with higher autism rates but admitted the evidence is not dispositive.
- Sam Stein and Will Sommer say he oversimplified contested research and misled by presenting tentative findings as probable causes.
Don't Announce Unvetted Science Publicly
- Avoid making authoritative public health claims unless the evidence is strong and vetted by experts.
- Sam Stein urges that RFK Jr. should not state uncertain science in a way the public will take as directive.
Danish Study Is Methodologically Contested
- The Danish study RFK referenced had disputed methodology and could not isolate circumcision from other pain-related factors or infections.
- Multiple subsequent studies have questioned the Danish findings and found no determinative link to autism.
