The Auron MacIntyre Show Power in 'Lord of the Rings' | Guest: The Middle-earth Mixer | 10/23/25
10 snips
Oct 24, 2025 Join Middle-earth Mixer, a passionate podcaster and Tolkien expert, as he delves into the nuanced themes of power in J.R.R. Tolkien's works. They explore the symbolic nature of the One Ring, discussing how Tolkien’s views on authority challenge simplistic interpretations. The conversation contrasts the failures of leaders like Denethor with the revitalization of Theoden, illustrating effective and ineffective leadership. Finally, they examine Tolkien's preferred model of decentralized monarchy as a solution to avoid the pitfalls of centralized power.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Ring As Illicit Authority
- The One Ring represents unlawful use of unlawful authority rather than a single allegory.
- Tolkien frames power as neutral; misuse (like Sauron’s) is the real danger.
How Gondor Lost Its Kings
- Isildur's failure to secure unified succession caused Gondor's decline and the rise of stewards.
- Arvedui's inability to assert his claim let inferior rulers and prideful stewards fracture rightful authority.
Power Must Be Exercised Rightly
- Tolkien values rightful authority exercised decisively, not blanket rejection of power.
- Vacuums or timid leaders invite inferior rule and greater harm to the people.
