Michael Schulman, author of 'Oscar Wars' and a staff writer at The New Yorker, dives into the chaotic and flamboyant history of the 1989 Oscars, often dubbed the worst ever. He discusses the eccentric production by Allan Carr, highlighting its bizarre opening featuring Snow White and Rob Lowe. Schulman reflects on the excesses of Hollywood at the time and critiques the industry's treatment of performers, especially women. He makes a case for why these notorious awards show moments are charmingly misunderstood and deserving of a second look.
The 1989 Academy Awards, deemed a disaster, featured an awkward opening number that alienated both audience and participants alike.
Producer Alan Carr's ambitious attempts to modernize the Oscars by introducing 'baton theory' revealed a significant disconnect with traditional expectations.
The fallout from the Oscars led to Carr's ostracization from Hollywood, showcasing the dangers of unchecked ambition and artistic hubris.
Deep dives
The Notorious 1989 Oscars
The conversation centers on the 1989 Academy Awards, often labeled as the worst Oscars ever. The notorious opening number, featuring Snow White and Rob Lowe, is highlighted as an example of excess and folly, running for over 11 minutes. Actors in attendance appeared visibly uncomfortable as the performance included various awkward interactions and surreal elements that defied the usual standards of the ceremony. The producers aimed for innovation but ended up with a chaotic showcase that many deemed humiliating and cringeworthy.
Alan Carr's Ambitious Vision
Producer Alan Carr's ambition for the Oscars stemmed from his desire to blend glamour with the modern era, steering away from traditional formats. He introduced concepts like 'baton theory', where presenters could introduce each other, and elevated the fashion stakes by consulting high-profile names in style. However, his decision to skip live performances of the nominated songs, deeming them 'turds', and instead create lavish production numbers reflected a disconnect from the audience's expectations. This ambitious vision ultimately contributed to the disastrous reception of the ceremony.
The Chaos of the Opening Number
The opening number, inspired by a San Francisco cabaret show, involved excessive spectacle, including a conga line and awkward collaborations with celebrities in attendance. It presented Snow White in a lighthearted manner, but the execution felt forced and uncomfortable, resulting in many stars avoiding interaction during the performance. Rob Lowe's questionable singing added to the chaos, leaving the audience perplexed and shocked. Celebrated filmmaker Barry Levinson and journalist Peter Bart noted that the atmosphere was palpably cringe-inducing, signifying a collective realization of the show's failure.
The Aftermath of a Fiasco
In the aftermath of the ceremony, Alan Carr faced immediate backlash as reviews labeled the event a total failure with strong criticisms across major platforms. Critics and audience members voiced their disdain, leading to an open letter signed by prominent Hollywood figures, further ostracizing Carr from the community he once sought to impress. Additionally, the Academy and Disney's trademark infringement lawsuit revealed that Carr had failed to clear the Snow White performance, further complicating the fallout. The negative publicity led to a significant decline in Carr's career and reputation, marking a dramatic turning point.
Lasting Impacts and Reflections
The disaster of the 1989 Oscars set the stage for change within the Academy Awards, prompting a reassessment of how the ceremony should be produced. Subsequent Oscars moved away from extravagant opening numbers, with Billy Crystal’s comedic approach becoming a staple. Alan Carr's legacy reflects the duality of ambition and hubris, illustrating how the pursuit of acceptance and recognition can lead to personal and professional downfalls. His story serves as a cautionary tale about the volatility of fame and the expectations that accompany it.
What do Lily Tomlin, Snow White, and Kenny Ortega have in common? They were all part of the 61st Academy Awards, a broadcast now remembered as the worst of all time, and masterminded by Allan Carr (lover of spectacle and producer of Grease). But awards season correspondent and New Yorker staff writer Michael Schulman is here to argue that the tackiest, most disastrous Oscars of all time might just be... unfairly maligned.
And to tell us what's bringing you joy and excitement right now, send us a voice memo (three minutes or shorter) at sloppyandalive (at) gmail (dot) com. We can't wait to hear from you.
