A young woman, Carolyn Killaby, goes missing in 1995 after a night out. The investigation uncovers a suspect with a criminal past and conflicting statements. Despite charges of murder, the victim's body remains missing. The case concludes tragically with the suspect's suicide and the family left without closure.
Spousal conflict escalates to tragic events leading to a missing person case.
Criminal background and actions of suspects play a crucial role in investigations.
There are limitations in the justice system, causing unresolved cases and emotional distress for families.
Deep dives
The Disappearance of Carolyn Killaby
Daniel Killaby returns home to find his wife, Carolyn, missing after a fight. Despite initially believing she might have left in anger, Daniel becomes concerned when she doesn't return home. Carolyn's car is found outside a nightclub, where witnesses report seeing her intoxicated. A man named Dennis Smith is identified as being with Carolyn that night, but his version of events raises suspicions, especially regarding a mysterious man who allegedly abducted her.
Investigation and Suspicion
As the investigation into Carolyn's disappearance unfolds, Dennis Smith's criminal background comes to light, including a past murder conviction. Detectives find inconsistencies in Dennis' accounts of the night Carolyn disappeared, leading to his identification as a suspect. Blood evidence matching Carolyn is found in Dennis' truck, and forensic analysis raises suspicions of foul play. Despite Dennis' attempts to deflect blame, investigators gather compelling evidence against him.
Arrest and Conviction
Following a nationwide search, Dennis Smith is apprehended in Florida after an encounter with law enforcement. He faces multiple charges related to Carolyn's disappearance, including first-degree murder. Despite his plea of innocence, detailed forensic analysis, including mitochondrial DNA testing, links him to the crime. Dennis is convicted of aggravated first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole, highlighting the failures of the parole system in preventing a repeat offender from committing further crimes.
Closure and Legal Actions
Despite Dennis' conviction, Carolyn's remains are never located, leaving her family with lingering questions and grief. Efforts to retrieve information about Carolyn's whereabouts, including appeals for assistance and a reward for information, remain unsuccessful. Daniel, cleared of any involvement, moves to Texas with his daughters, while Carolyn's family honors her memory with memorials and markers. Legal actions against the state showcase the impact of oversight failures in Dennis' case.
Conclusion and Legacy
Amid the aftermath of Dennis Smith's imprisonment and subsequent death by suicide, questions surrounding Carolyn's disappearance persist, with her ultimate fate remaining unknown. The unresolved case sheds light on the importance of thorough investigations and the challenges faced in locating missing persons without definitive evidence. Despite the legal closure brought by Dennis' conviction, the emotional toll on Carolyn's family underscores the enduring impact of such tragedies on loved ones left behind.
When a young woman goes missing in November 1995, no one knew just how close they were to a monster lurking in the area. What starts as a night out after an argument with her husband… ends in tragedy that’s left the family with so many questions.
If you or anyone you know is thinking about suicide, emotional support can be reached by calling or texting the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988, or by calling the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255).
And if you or a loved one wants to explore treatment for substance use, you can seek help by calling 211, or visiting www.211.org.
Did you know you can listen to this episode ad-free? Join the Fan Club! Visit crimejunkie.app/library/ to view the current membership options and policies.
