Peter Schwartzstein, an environmental journalist and author of "The Heat and the Fury," dives into the alarming correlation between climate change and violence. He discusses how vulnerable communities become hotspots for violence due to climate-induced stresses and governance failures. Schwartzstein also explores the psychological impact of environmental degradation, introducing the term 'solastalgia.' He warns that feelings of abandonment might provoke unrest even in stable democracies, as mental health and identity are increasingly tied to our changing planet.
Climate change exacerbates violence in vulnerable communities due to governmental failures in meeting public expectations for essential resources.
Psychological effects of climate change, including isolation and despair, lead individuals to irrational behaviors and increased susceptibility to violence.
Collaboration and resource sharing among communities can reduce tensions and promote peaceful coexistence, offering solutions to climate-related disputes.
Deep dives
Public Expectations and State Capacity
A significant contributor to climate-related violence arises from the disparity between public expectations of governmental services and the state's ability to fulfill those expectations. When essential resources like food, water, and sanitation decline, dissatisfaction among citizens surges. Wealthier nations, particularly in Europe, tend to have high expectations of their states, and if governments fail to meet these demands in times of climate stress, the resulting public unrest may fuel support for extremist parties. Such parties often exploit these complexities, providing simplistic narratives to gain political leverage in a rapidly changing climate landscape.
The Dynamics of Violence in Vulnerable Communities
Climate change significantly exacerbates existing tensions in vulnerable communities by pressuring societal fractures. As environmental stresses mount, the likelihood of violence increases when communities can no longer rely on their social structures for support. In regions like Iraq, exacerbating factors such as inequality and resource scarcity have seen those feeling abandoned by their governments become more susceptible to recruitment by extremist groups like ISIS. Thus, the erosion of community ties, alongside climate-induced stresses, creates situations where violence becomes a response rather than seeking mutual aid.
Mental Health and Trauma Linked to Climate Change
The psychological impact of climate change manifests strongly within communities that experience recurring and intensifying environmental crises. A growing body of research links deteriorating mental health and increased violence to both environmental degradation and societal breakdown. In rural areas of regions suffering from climate impacts, individuals not only contend with changing landscapes but also lose social connections as their loved ones migrate, leading to feelings of isolation and despair. This psychological strain creates fertile ground for irrational behaviors, including violence, often compounding existing vulnerabilities.
Governance and Climate-Related Violence
Foremost, poor governance exacerbates the impacts of climate change in already stressed regions, highlighting a crucial link between governance and violence. In areas where local leadership fails to address climate-induced challenges effectively, public unrest tends to rise as citizens feel neglected. This failure to provide basic services or security fosters an environment ripe for conflict, particularly in areas historically reliant on agriculture, now pushed to the brink by climate change. As governance quality continues to decline, communities face escalating pressures, potentially spiraling into violence as they struggle to meet their needs.
Resource Sharing as a Mitigation Strategy
Sharing resources across communities can help alleviate tensions and reduce the likelihood of violence exacerbated by scarcity, a concept increasingly recognized in international discussions. Initiatives for transboundary cooperation have gained traction, particularly in water-scarce regions, promoting collaboration rather than confrontation. Finding common ground in resource management not only fosters mutual dependence but also potentially ameliorates historical grievances, creating pathways for peaceful coexistence. While the challenges remain significant, successful mediation efforts in various regions showcase that constructive dialogues can yield effective outcomes in mitigating climate-driven disputes.
Peter Schwartzstein is an environmental journalist and researcher, and author of The Heat and the Fury which investigates the relationship between violence and climate change. He joins me to explain how a changing climate is creating pockets of violence in poor and rural communities around the world. Local and national governance failures are driving violence, with the changes to the earth's body being felt in our own.
Taking us all around the world, Peter explains the particular set of circumstances which generate violence, given communities often do their utmost to avoid clashing. Climate change alone does not brew violence, but combined with a loss of sense of self and an awareness of wealth disparity, people turn to extremes to protect themselves from further abandonment. We then turn this model on this West, hypothesising how violence could spring up in liberal democracies where increasingly people are feeling let down by their elected officials. Finally, we explore the trauma of watching the earth break down around us, and how people's minds are being lost with the stability we once knew and relied upon, inspiring behaviour that was also once previously unimaginable.
Planet: Critical is 100% independent and community-powered. If you value it, and have the means, become a paid subscriber today.