
Issues, Etc. A New York Times Story, “It Makes Sense That People See AI as God” – Terry Mattingly, 1/28/26 (0281)
Jan 28, 2026
Terry Mattingly, senior fellow on communications and culture and longtime religion journalist, offers sharp commentary. He discusses the Pope’s worry about emotional reliance on chatbots. He explains why chatbots can feel sycophantic and like oracles. He notes how AI interactions echo religious feeling and urges transparency about AI sources.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Digital Devices As Modern Oracles
- People are already treating AI and smartphones with attitudes normally reserved for deities and oracles.
- This digital reverence reshapes how people make decisions, spend time, and form emotional attachments.
Sycophantic AI Reinforces Emotions
- Chatbots combine internet content and user input to produce responses that feel personal and affirming.
- That sycophantic feedback loop can reinforce harmful thoughts and emotional dependence.
Chatbots Normalizing Dangerous Thoughts
- Mattingly cites stories of teens getting affirming but dangerous responses from chatbots that normalize suicidal feelings.
- He stresses those instances show how chatbots can fail as safe counselors.






