Sam Harris speaks with Greg Lukianoff about free speech, cancel culture, the origins of political correctness, boundaries of free speech, technology's impact on ideas, social media cancellations, justified cancellations, Hunter Biden laptop story, dealing with Trump in media, state of higher education, and more. Greg Lukianoff is an advocate for free speech, President & CEO of FIRE, co-author of 'The Coddling of the American Mind'.
Protecting free speech in academia and society is vital for fostering diverse opinions and challenging perspectives.
Social media exacerbates cancel culture, leading to self-censorship and mob justice, impacting institutions like academia and journalism.
Cancel culture, influenced by social media, differs from McCarthyism in scope, raising concerns about censorship, truth discovery, and institutional credibility.
Academia faces challenges of cancel culture from left-leaning administrators, sparking debates on justifiable cancellations, journalistic ethics, and promoting viewpoint diversity.
Deep dives
Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) and the Fight for Free Speech
Greg Lukianov, the president of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE), is at the forefront of defending free speech. FIRE, founded in 1999, tackles cases where individuals face consequences for their speech. Greg's background and passion for free speech highlight the organization's mission to protect individuals in academic and public settings. The historic importance of free speech and the need to address cancel culture are central to their discussions.
The Evolution of Free Speech Boundaries and Academic Freedom
The concept of free speech extends beyond legal restrictions, encompassing the cultural acceptance of diverse opinions. Greg advocates for opinion absolutism, where expressing views, even controversial ones, is protected. Differentiating between protected speech and harmful behaviors like harassment or defamation is crucial. Greg emphasizes the importance of a robust marketplace of ideas to challenge and refine perspectives.
Challenges of Cancel Culture and Social Media Influence
Cancel culture, marked by efforts to silence individuals for their views, has intensified with social media platforms enabling swift backlash. Greg highlights the impact of social media on institutions like academia and journalism, leading to self-censorship and mob justice. Platforms play a crucial role in moderating content, balancing protection against misinformation and preserving diverse viewpoints.
McCarthyism vs. Cancel Culture: Examining Historical and Contemporary Impacts
Comparing McCarthyism to cancel culture reveals distinct differences in scale and characteristics. While McCarthyism targeted individuals for alleged communist ties, cancel culture today affects a wider range, with social media fueling swift and widespread condemnation. The prevalence of cancel culture, reflecting societal shifts and technological influences, raises concerns about censorship, truth discovery, and institutional credibility.
Cancel Culture in Academia: A Left-Leaning Phenomenon
Cancel culture, often associated with the left, is a prevalent issue in academia. Administrators, primarily left-leaning, hold significant power in academia and make decisions on firing based on perceived affiliations or media sources. Threats from legislatures, like the Stop Woke Act, challenged academic freedom and led to legal action by organizations like FIRE and the ACLU.
Debate on Cancellation and Academic Integrity
Debates arose on justifiable cancellations and viewpoints in academia. Cases like the Hunter Biden laptop incident showcased the complexity journalists face in reporting controversial topics before elections. The balance between fact-checking and time constraints in reporting ethical or scandalous news was central to the discussion on censorship and journalistic integrity.
Challenges and Solutions in Higher Education
Higher education faces significant challenges, including administrative bloat, cancel culture, and lack of viewpoint diversity. Solutions proposed include reducing the bureaucracy in universities, promoting intellectual diversity among faculty, and encouraging alternative higher education models like the University of Austin. Lawsuits and reputation damage emerge as potential drivers for change in holding institutions accountable for protecting academic freedom.
Sam Harris speaks with Greg Lukianoff about free speech and cancel culture. They discuss the origins of political correctness, free speech and its boundaries, the bedrock principle of the First Amendment, technology and the marketplace of ideas, epistemic anarchy, social media and cancellation, comparisons to McCarthyism, self-censorship by professors, cancellation from the Left and Right, justified cancellations, the Hunter Biden laptop story, how to deal with Trump in the media, the state of higher education in America, and other topics.
Greg Lukianoff is the President & CEO of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE). He earned his undergraduate degree from American University and his law degree from Stanford, and he worked for the ACLU of Northern California and other organizations before joining FIRE in 2001. He is one of America’s most passionate defenders of free speech. He has written about the issue in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and The Washington Post. He also co-wrote The Coddling of the American Mind with Jonathan Haidt and, most recently, The Canceling of the American Mind with Rikki Schlott.
Learning how to train your mind is the single greatest investment you can make in life. That’s why Sam Harris created the Waking Up app. From rational mindfulness practice to lessons on some of life’s most important topics, join Sam as he demystifies the practice of meditation and explores the theory behind it.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
