Paul Niehaus, an economist from UC San Diego and co-founder of GiveDirectly, dives into the surprising drop in global extreme poverty from 44% in 1981 to just 9% today. He advocates for the effectiveness of direct cash transfers, highlighting how they empower individuals and challenge traditional aid paradigms. Niehaus discusses the significant impact of gender dynamics in fund distribution, critiques the 'teach a man to fish' approach, and underscores the need for a balanced understanding of poverty that merges quantitative metrics with community values.
Extreme poverty has dramatically decreased from 44% to 9% in the last 40 years, demonstrating its malleable nature rather than being an unchangeable condition.
Economic growth, enhanced education, and job opportunities are vital drivers in poverty reduction, showcasing diverse pathways beyond mere cash transfers.
The complexity of poverty dynamics emphasizes the need for policies that support both immediate relief and long-term growth strategies to prevent regression.
Deep dives
The Decline of Extreme Poverty
Extreme poverty has significantly decreased over the past four decades, with the percentage of the global population living on less than $2.15 per day dropping from about 40% to under 10%. This remarkable shift highlights that mass poverty is not an unchangeable reality but a malleable condition influenced by various global developments. Research indicates that two billion people lived in extreme poverty 35 years ago, whereas that number has now decreased to just under 700 million. Understanding the dynamics of how this change occurred is crucial for continuing to address those still affected by poverty.
The Role of Economic Growth
Economic growth is a significant factor driving poverty reduction, as evidenced by advancements observed in countries like India, China, and Indonesia. As these nations developed, many individuals migrated to cities for better opportunities, while others found ways to uplift their living standards without relocating. Notably, the majority of individuals escaping extreme poverty were not solely reliant on cash transfers but made improvements through various means, including enhanced education and job opportunities. Hence, the focus on economic policies that stimulate growth is crucial for further reductions in overall poverty rates.
Churn in Poverty Dynamics
An important aspect of poverty dynamics is the identified phenomenon of churn, where individuals experience fluctuations in their poverty status. While many people succeed in climbing out of poverty, there are also substantial numbers who fall back due to unforeseen setbacks such as illness or natural disasters. Studies reveal that in countries like Indonesia and South Africa, the number of households that remained consistently poor over years is surprisingly low, indicating high rates of upward mobility. Therefore, it is critical to understand the dual nature of poverty reduction—both progress and regression—to develop effective intervention strategies.
Diverse Pathways Out of Poverty
The journey out of extreme poverty is not one-size-fits-all, as families employ a variety of strategies to improve their economic situations. Evidence suggests that individuals can thrive while staying in agriculture, starting small businesses, or moving to urban areas, thereby refuting the notion that migration to cities is the only effective route for escaping poverty. The study emphasizes the importance of recognizing multiple successful pathways to prosperity while tailoring support based on local contexts and conditions. This personalized approach acknowledges the complexity of poverty alleviation and allows for effective development strategies.
The Implications for Policy and Interventions
To sustain and enhance the momentum of poverty reduction, policymakers must adopt evidence-based approaches that prioritize both cash transfers and economic growth initiatives. Research suggests that direct cash transfers can provide immediate relief and enable recipients to make choices best suited to their needs, leading to enhanced well-being and investment in their futures. Meanwhile, programs facilitating job creation and access to education are essential for long-term solutions. A balanced strategy incorporating various effective methods is recommended to not only alleviate extreme poverty but also prevent those who rise above it from falling back down the poverty ladder.
In 1981, an estimated 44 percent of the global population lived in extreme poverty. In 2019, that number shrank to just 9 percent. We often think of poverty as a trap, but recent research shows it doesn’t have to be. The economist and co-founder of GiveDirectly, Paul Niehaus, explains how extreme poverty fell over the past 40 years and how it could be eliminated for good.
Further reading:
“How Poverty Fell,” by Vincent Armentano, Paul Niehaus, and Tom Vogl
Get more from your favorite Atlantic voices when you subscribe. You’ll enjoy unlimited access to Pulitzer-winning journalism, from clear-eyed analysis and insight on breaking news to fascinating explorations of our world. Subscribe today at TheAtlantic.com/podsub.
