In this discussion, Chris McGreal, a writer for The Guardian US with a deep background in South African politics, analyzes Trump's controversial stance on South Africa. They explore why the president is concerned about land reforms affecting white farmers, linking it to a media narrative. McGreal delves into the complexities of crime rates and historical victimization narratives, critiquing how figures like Elon Musk shape discourse around race and ownership. The podcast highlights the intersection of politics, history, and individual narratives in shaping current perceptions.
Trump's executive order to cut aid to South Africa and grant asylum to Afrikaners reflects his focus on white grievance narratives amidst historical land reforms.
The influence of Silicon Valley figures, particularly Elon Musk and Peter Thiel, complicates perceptions of South Africa's transition from apartheid and shapes political attitudes toward equity reforms.
Deep dives
Political Asylum for Afrikaners
U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order cutting financial aid to South Africa while simultaneously granting political asylum to the Afrikaner population. This dual action reflects Trump's long-standing focus on the perceived plight of white South Africans, particularly in light of land reform policies initiated by the South African government aimed at addressing historical inequalities. Critics view this move as an opportunistic embrace of white grievance in a nation transitioning from apartheid to a more equitable society. This order stands out against the backdrop of broader U.S. immigration policies that have restricted asylum for many other groups.
Misinformation and Land Reform
At the center of the controversy surrounding Trump's executive order is the Expropriation Act, a law that allows limited instances of land seizure without compensation. Afrikaner organizations have exaggerated the implications of this law, framing it as a systemic attack on the white minority, despite the fact that whites own a disproportionate amount of land compared to their population. The historical context shows a stark contrast where legislative efforts since apartheid aimed to redistribute land to correct past injustices. This exaggerated narrative attempts to recast Afrikaners as victims while ignoring the reality of ongoing disparities in land ownership and wealth.
Impact of Silicon Valley Influencers
Influential figures in Silicon Valley, often referred to as the PayPal mafia, have played a significant role in shaping Trump's attitudes toward South Africa. Notable among these are Elon Musk and Peter Thiel, both of whom have personal histories linked to the country and a shared libertarian philosophy that challenges post-apartheid reforms. Their narratives often frame government measures aimed at creating equity as racially discriminatory against whites, contributing to a false narrative of white victimization. This dynamic illustrates how business interests, particularly Musk's projects, intertwine with political rhetoric and policies concerning South Africa, potentially affecting both national and international relations.
Among his recent executive orders, Donald Trump moved to halt aid to South Africa over a land law and extended political asylum to South Africa’s white Afrikaner population.
Where does Trump’s seemingly spotty understanding of South Africa come from? How could having close advisors who grew up in apartheid-era South Africa, like Elon Musk, influence him?
Guest: Chris McGreal, writer for The Guardian US who reported from South Africa during the end of apartheid.
Want more What Next? Join Slate Plus to unlock full, ad-free access to What Next and all your other favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the What Next show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme, Rob Gunther, and Ethan Oberman.