

Rescuing Evolutionary Theory from Darwinian Mythology
Apr 4, 2025
Robert Shedinger, the Wilford A. Johnson Chair of Biblical Studies at Luther College, dives deep into the complexities of evolutionary theory and its intersection with religion. He contrasts Darwin's public and private views on natural selection, revealing gaps in evidence that challenge the traditional narrative. Shedinger also discusses historical critiques of Darwinism by notable scientists and explores Darwin's unfinished manuscript and its implications. His insights encourage a reevaluation of the philosophical themes in Darwin’s work.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Non-Empirical Support for Natural Selection
- Scientists' support for natural selection isn't always based on evidence.
- Some base it on ideological biases towards naturalistic causes.
Weismann's Ideological Bias
- August Weismann admitted his support for natural selection wasn't evidence-based.
- His ideological bias favored naturalistic explanations for evolution.
Unconventional Beliefs of Geneticists
- Early population geneticists like Sewell Wright and Ronald Fisher held unconventional beliefs.
- Wright was a panpsychist, and Fisher believed natural selection was the only option, excluding non-physical causes.