Judith Butler on the Global Backlash to L.G.B.T.Q. Rights
Mar 18, 2024
auto_awesome
Judith Butler discusses gender as a social construct and the backlash to trans rights. They explore the concept of performativity in gender and the fear-mongering surrounding gender identity. Also, they talk about nonviolent solutions in political conflicts.
Judith Butler's work challenges gender norms by asserting gender as a social construct shaped by cultural behaviors.
Conservative backlash against trans rights perpetuates a false perception of gender as a destructive force.
Deep dives
Influential Ideas on Gender by Judith Butler
Judith Butler's work, especially 'Gender Trouble', introduced the idea that gender is a social construct shaped by cultural behaviors, challenging the binary notion of gender. These concepts, although widely accepted by younger generations, face strong opposition from conservative political forces such as the Vatican and Vladimir Putin.
Performativity of Gender
Butler's concept of gender performativity emphasizes that individuals enact social norms through their behaviors, shaping their gender identity. Despite misunderstandings that performativity implies fakeness, Butler clarifies that it signifies the daily enactment of social norms that contribute to one's gender sense.
Challenges to Gender Norms and Pronouns
Butler addresses societal resistance towards diverse gender expressions, emphasizing the importance of respecting individuals' pronouns as a way to acknowledge their identity. The evolving understanding of gender beyond binary divisions sparks discussions in various communities, highlighting the need for compassionate acceptance and active listening to individuals' self-identifications.
Long before gender theory became a principal target of the right, it existed principally in academic circles. And one of the leading thinkers in the field was the philosopher Judith Butler. In “Gender Trouble” (from 1990) and in other works, Butler popularized ideas about gender as a social construct, a “performance,” a matter of learned behavior. Those ideas proved highly influential for a younger generation, and Butler became the target of traditionalists who abhorred them. A protest at which Butler was burned in effigy, depicted as a witch, inspired their new book, “Who’s Afraid of Gender?” It covers the backlash to trans rights in which conservatives from the Vatican to Vladimir Putin create a “phantasm” of gender as a destructive force. “Obviously, nobody who is thinking about gender . . . is saying you can’t be a mother, that you can’t be a father, or we’re not using those words anymore,” they tell David Remnick. “Or we’re going to take your sex away.” They also discuss Butler’s identification as nonbinary after many years of identifying as a woman. “The young people gave me the ‘they,’ ” as Butler puts it. “At the end of ‘Gender Trouble,’ in 1990, I said, ‘Why do we restrict ourselves to thinking there are only men and women?’ . . . This generation has come along with the idea of being nonbinary. [It] never occurred to me! Then I thought, Of course I am. What else would I be? . . . I just feel gratitude to the younger generation, they gave me something wonderful. That also takes humility of a certain kind.”