Venture capitalist Chris Dixon discusses the potential of blockchain technology in changing the internet and the world. The podcast explores the challenges of crypto in solving internet problems, the dominance of top internet companies, the impact of the attract-extract cycle on user experience and innovation, the combination of decentralization and centralization in networks, and the speculative mania in the crypto sector.
Crypto may not be the ultimate solution to the internet's problems.
Blockchain networks offer a hybrid model, combining decentralization with financial opportunities.
Deep dives
Crypto's Prophet Faces Criticism and Doubts
In this podcast episode, the challenges faced by Chris Dixon, a prominent figure in the crypto industry, are discussed. Despite his success as a crypto-adventure capitalist and his belief in the potential of blockchain technology, Dixon's ideas have been met with ridicule and skepticism. To counter this, he decides to write a book, arguing that the problem with the internet lies in its technical architecture, which gives excessive power to corporations. He believes that blockchain technology can decentralize this architecture and shift power back to the people. However, the podcast challenges Dixon's argument, pointing out that the problems of the internet also stem from the technical architecture of blockchains, and that the grand promises of crypto fall short. The podcast highlights the dominance of corporate networks and the power law dynamics that perpetuate inequality and monopolies. While Dixon's arguments are well-reasoned, they overlook factors like human psychology and the nature of online competition. The podcast concludes that while the promise of crypto is compelling, it may not be the ultimate solution to the internet's problems.
The Three Types of Digital Networks
The podcast delves into Chris Dixon's framework for understanding digital networks, which categorizes them into three types: protocol networks, corporate networks, and blockchain networks. Protocol networks are decentralized systems, analogous to natural languages, that enable computers to communicate with each other. Corporate networks, such as social media platforms, are centralized and controlled by corporations, often backed by venture capitalists. Blockchain networks, on the other hand, have networks with decision-making bodies and operate on immutable code written on the blockchain. Participants in blockchain networks gain governance rights and economic benefits through owning crypto tokens. Dixon argues that blockchain networks offer a hybrid model, combining the decentralization of protocols with the incentives and financial opportunities of corporate networks.
The Dilemma of Speculation and Fraud
The podcast addresses the speculative mania and scams that emerged in the crypto space in the early 2020s. While Dixon acknowledges the negative impact of speculation on the sector, his treatment of the issue is deemed inadequate by the podcast. Dixon attributes the problem to two distinct cultures within the blockchain community: one focused on building networks and the other on speculation and gambling. However, the podcast argues that the speculative nature of crypto is inherent in its technology, with financial incentives and comparison on investment returns overshadowing other aspects. The attract-extract cycle, where early adopters extract maximum yield before moving on to other projects, further exacerbates the problem. While Dixon discusses the need for regulation, the podcast highlights the fundamental challenges of governance in decentralized blockchain networks.
The Limitations and Unfulfilled Promise of Blockchain
The podcast critically examines the limitations and unfulfilled promise of blockchain technology. While Dixon's arguments for the potential of blockchain networks are compelling, the podcast questions the effectiveness of this technology in practice. It points out that many crypto projects failed to deliver on their promises, and the risks of fraud and scams have been ever-present. The podcast emphasizes the need for practical utility beyond financial incentives to drive adoption and disrupt corporate networks effectively. It also suggests that other technological advancements, such as AI or platform shifts, may offer more promising solutions to the challenges facing the internet. Ultimately, the podcast concludes that while crypto has its merits, it may not be the ultimate panacea for the problems of the internet.
Chris Dixon, the patron saint of crypto, is still preaching the gospel.
In this essay, Every lead writer Evan Armstrong deconstructs Dixon’s new book, Read Write Own, in which the venture capitalist proffers his still-faithful argument for how crypto and blockchain technology can change the internet—and the world.
Evan isn’t convinced. “I finished it believing that blockchains can solve niche use cases that rely on the technology’s properties,” he writes. “I was equally convinced that crypto’s promise has been greatly inflated.” While Dixon diagnoses many of the internet’s problems, crypto won’t be the thing that saves it.
Over crypto? Still all-in? Let us know what you think.
If you found this essay interesting, please like, subscribe, comment, and share. If you want more from Every on cutting-edge technology, check out our weekly podcast series, How Do You Use ChatGPT?, where host Dan Shipper interviews luminaries and experts like Tyler Cowen, David Perell, and Sahil Lavingia.