

What’s a Win? - with Dr. Tal Becker
9 snips Jun 12, 2025
In this discussion, Tal Becker, former Legal Advisor of the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs and expert in peace negotiations, dives into the complex notion of 'victory' in the ongoing conflict with Hamas. He questions what victory truly entails and examines the implications for Israeli society. The conversation also touches on historical military philosophies, the global perceptions surrounding the Israel-Palestine discourse, and the potential impact of statehood recognition on the peace process. Becker's insights aim to clarify the often convoluted narratives that shape these discussions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Israel's War Objectives Explored
- Israel's war objectives include returning hostages, ending Hamas threats, and removing Hamas from Gaza.
- While military defeat of Hamas is progressing, achieving a sustainable post-Hamas reality remains highly challenging.
Two Views of Victory in War
- Victory in war can mean either total military domination or dismantling the enemy's strategy.
- Defeating Hamas militarily alone won't suffice without undermining its ideological appeal and regional legitimacy.
Lopsided International War Narrative
- The international debate rarely addresses Hamas's initial aggression; it focuses almost exclusively on Israel's responses.
- This imbalance skews perceptions and overlooks the origins of conflict provocations.